Reappraisals and asking for grade changes

I have received many requests of the years from students asking for their grades to be changed. Typical notes or email might say "I received a 58 (D+) in your course and I really need a C+ to graduate."

First, let me explain what I do when I finalize my course marks. Every exam that has a failing mark (<50) is required to be re-evaluated. I do this. Second, I review every grade that is calculated and I ask myself "Is this a fair representation of the student's performance, and my opinion of what the student deserves?" When I do not think it is a fair mark, I review all the grading components in the course to see if I made any mistakes or if any other grade can be justified, within the announced parameters of the grading scheme. Third, every grade below C+ (the old threshhold for counting within the BAS major) is checked an additional time.

As you can see, I put a lot of effort into the grades that I submit.

So what if you are not satisfied with your mark?

Before you request a formal reappraisal, I always am prepared to review your examination and grade calculations another time. If there is an error, I want to get it corrected without you having to go through the formal petitioning process.

Also, before requesting a formal reappraisal, consider the situation and do a little arithmetic. If you got 52% and need a C+, which begins at 65%, an exam reappraisal would have to find 32 more marks to get you the requisite grades (assuming a 100 mark final worth 40% of the course grade). Does this seem reasonable? You be the judge.

Remember you do have the right to request a formal reappraisal

Do Not Use the Following Arguments to Get Me to Reconsider Your Grade:

I cannot graduate because my average is too low

If your average is too low, then you must of done poorly in other courses as well. What is it about my course and the way I have marked that makes you think I should change your grade?

I worked really hard in your course

I don't doubt you have. The courses that I teach require hard work.

I did really good in your course. I deserve an A, not a B.

First, learn some grammar. You did well, not good. Second, the grade "B" does mean "Good". An "A" is for students whose performance is "Excellent".

I TRY TO MAKE SURE THAT EVERY STUDENT GETS EVERY MARK THAT THEY DESERVE AND EARN. YOU EARN GRADES BY DEMONSTRATING THAT YOU UNDERSTAND THE MATERIAL TAUGHT IN THE COURSE.

If you need to get in touch, please send mail to amarshal@yorku.ca