[ADDRESSING THE ACADEMY]

"The tradition of the oppressed teaches us that the ‘state of emergency' in which we live is not the exception but the rule...There is no document of civilization which is not at the same time a document of barbarism. And just as such a document is not free of barbarism, barbarism taints also the manner in which it was transmitted from one owner to another. A historical materialist therefore dissociates himself from it as far as possible. He regards it as his task to brush history against the grain."
Walter Benjamin, "Theses on the Philosophy of History."

CE MOT VIENT D'UN COLLEGUE EN ALLEMAND, ARND BOHM, A l'UNIVERSITE CARLETON.

J'ENCOURAGE LES MEMBRES DE L'ACS A SOUTENIR NOS COLLEGUES EN LANGUES MODERNES POUR ARRETER LA FERMETURE DE LEURS UNITES. ECRIVEZ UN MOT AUX INDIVIDUS INDIQUES CI-DESSOUS POUR PROTESTER L'ABANDON DES LANGUES MODERNES DANS LES UNIVERSITES CANADIENNES. L'ANNEE DERNIERE ON A EU L'EXPERIENCE DE CONCORDIA OU ON A ESSAYE DE FERMER LE PROGRAMME DE FRANCAIS (DANS UNE VILLE FRANCOPHONE!!), MAINTENANT ON ESSAIE D'ELIMINER LES SCIENCES HUMAINES (DISCIPLINES INUTILES, CELA VA DE SOI!!) A CARLETON.

THIS MESSAGE IS FROM OUR COLLEAGUE IN GERMAN STUDIES, ARND BOHM, AT CARLETON UNIVERSITY.

I ENCOURAGE ALL MEMBERS OF CSA TO SUPPORT OUR COLLEAGUES IN MODERN LANGUAGES AT CARLETON UNIVERSITY. SEND A MESSAGE TO THE UNIVERSITY OFFICIALS INDICATED BELOW TO REGISTER YOUR PROTEST AGAINST THE ABANDONMENT OF MODERN LANGUES IN CANADIAN UNIVERSITIES. LAST YEAR WE HAD THE EXAMPLE OF THE ATTEMPTED CLOSURE OF FRENCH STUDIES AT CONCORDIA (IN A FRANCOPHONE CITY!!), NOW WE SEE AN ATTEMPT TO ELIMINATE CORE HUMANITIES DISCIPLINES (USELESS THINGS THAT THEY OBVIOUSLY ARE!!) AT CARLETON.

From: Arnd Bohm

Date: Sat, 22 Nov 1997 19:31:21 -0500 (EST)

Dear Colleagues,

This is a short version of a longer text which I have already sent but has not yet been distributed by the server. On Thursday, Nov. 20, the Dean of Arts and Social Sciences convened a meeting of the School of Languages, Literatures and Comparative Literary Studies to announce that he would recommend to Senate the closure of all our graduate and undergraduate programs in: German, Spanish, Italian, Russian, Comparative Literature and Classics.

The reason given was financial: we are too expensive because the total enrolments are small. Without going into details, I assure you that not only were the Dean's figures false, but that we are quite normal in student numbers when compared across Canada and the USA. Despite declining Arts enrolments, we have held steady. But no numbers we produce have any impact. Our MA program has appraised well with the Ontario Council of Graduate Studies; academic quality is not the argument being used against us.

To give you an idea of the "reasoning" at work, here is a quotation from the Ottawa Citizen, based on a press conference President Van Loon held Nov. 20:

"The cuts must be made and job losses are inevitable he [Van Loon] said. `We can't play around with smoke and mirrors.' Some teachers who lose full-time jobs could return as sessional instructors, who will play a larger part in teaching at the university. This would be a big cost saving, Mr. Van Loon said, since a sessional instructor is paid $7,000 to teach one course, while a tenured professor making $70,000 a year might teach two courses."

Because of a special clause in our collective agreement, the closure of this program would mean that all 22 full-time faculty can be declared redundant and laid off as of May 1, 1998, even though they have tenure. Includes me, folks. Our faculty association feels that this could be the test of a new model for reorganizing Ontario universities: close individual programs and thereby circumvent tenure. The Dean and Vice-President (Academic) are convinced that closing the language and literature programs (including Classics!) will not have negative consequences for Carleton's image. I hope and believe that the German unit at Carleton has a good reputation out there. If you could communicate that, as well as anything about how such sweeping cuts might be seen across Canada in relation to Carleton's image, it would be a help.

Because of the postal strike, and because the Senate will make its decision on November 28 (they moved the date ahead from Dec. 5!) I would ask you to fax or e-mail the following people directly and immediately:

Dr. Richard Van Loon
President
Carleton University
fax: 613 520-4474
email: richard_van_loon@carleton.ca

Dr. J. W. ApSimon
Vice-President (Research and External)
Carleton University
fax: 613 520-2689
email: john_apsimon@carleton.ca

Dr. G.S. Adam
Vice-President (Academic)
Carleton University
fax: 613 520-2536
email: stuart_adam@carleton.ca

Dr. R.C. Blockley
Dean of Graduate Studies
Carleton University
fax: 613 520-4049
email: roger_blockley@carleton.ca

If you email, add me to the list of addresses and I will forward copies to the other members of Senate:
arnd_bohm@carleton.ca

Please give this appeal wide distribution. Many thanks, and best wishes, Arnd Bohm

[ADDRESSING THE ACADEMY] ATA homepage send comments to ATA ATA archive Links page