Call for Papers
Intersections 2006
Adjunct Workshop
Keynotes
Schedule
Abstracts
Contact Us
Info
|
Abstracts
|
Saturday March, 25 |
|
9:15am |
Off the Map: Portraits of contested Toronto |
|
10:30am |
Lost in Transition: Borders, Surfaces and Translation |
|
1:30pm |
ADJUNCT WORKSHOP:ePOLITICS, POLICY, COMMUNICATION & CULTURE' |
|
2:45pm |
Identity Politics and Policy |
|
4:00pm |
Advocacy and Criticism |
|
|
|
|
Sunday March, 26 |
|
9:30am |
Spatial Orbits:
Ever (R)evolving Personal Spaces and their Outer Effects |
|
10:45am |
Streetscapes: Negotiating the Urban Environment |
|
1:45pm |
Where do you want to go today?:
Tourism, Technology and Transformation |
|
3:00pm |
tranSfOrMAtions |
|
4:15pm |
Consuming Territories: Ecologies and Economies of
Popular Culture |
|
|
|
Saturday March 25
Eaton Lecture Theatre - Rogers Communication Centre
9:15 am |
Off the Map: Portraits of Contested Toronto
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Bob Hanke |
|
1. |
Narcotography:
Mapping the Social Geography of Addiction in Toronto
Chris Smith,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture,
York and Ryerson Universities |
In October 2005, the City of Toronto released the
Toronto Drug Strategy report. Identifying crack cocaine as the
most prevalent street drug being used in the city, the report
openly addresses the particularities of Toronto's narcotic urban
landscape, which, unlike Vancouver, is highly decentralized,
"spread throughout the city, [and] often hidden from view". What forces and factors are responsible for shaping and
influencing the landscape of addiction and drug use within
cities? How do processes of gentrification/ghettoization, segregation/
congregation and socio-spatial polarization contribute to
processes of marginalization, exclusion, and alienation as they relate to the figure of the addict? How can critical social geography
lead to a more nuanced understanding of the relationship
between addiction and urban space?
Perhaps the most controversial aspect of the Toronto
Drug Strategy report concerns the recommendation that the city should carry-out
a study to assess the need for and practicality
of implementing a safe/supervised consumption site in the
city, consisting of a "legally sanctioned, low-threshold
facility that allows the consumption of pre-obtained drugs under
supervision in a non-judgmental environment". Pointing directly
to the visibility of drug using communities in urban space, the
report suggests that safe consumptions sites "evolved from
efforts to reduce public nuisance associated with open injection
drug use". In his seminal essay, "The Rhetoric of Drugs",
Derrida asks: "What do we hold against the drug addict?" Both
Derrida's essay, and the discourse contained within the Toronto
drug strategy report indicate that the answer can be found by
examining notions of visibility and public space as they relate
to user communities. Situating the work within the broader
historical relationship between addiction, modernity and the
city, this project will examine the contemporary social geography
of addiction in Toronto, arguing that the recent discourse
concerning the implementation of safe consumption sites needs
to be carefully considered in light of the larger forces associated
with capitalist urban redevelopment: surveillance and/as social
sanitization.
|
|
|
2. |
Submerged Environments:Taking Notice of Ecologies of Abjection
Neil Balan,
Division of Humanities, York University |
This paper is an intervention
directed at the zones inhabited and made habitable by Toronto's
impoverished and
marginalized; more specifically, substance-users and persons
afflicted with chronic mental-health problems with whom I contact
and work in a harm-reduction context. Conceptualized as "clients" requiring
provisional "services", they are themselves
mediators endowed with an efficacy all their own. Lacking in
terms of stable monetary capital, these mediators enable a different
set of symbolic powers and bodies of knowledge rooted in
a mode of abject ecology. In relation to ergonomic efficiency
and
economizing energy as the allocation of scare actual and potential
resources both flowing inward and out of these mediators
(subjects/actors/selves) operate functionally within a particular
submerged space, effectively beyond the axial horizons of Saskia
Sassen's often-cited vertical and horizontal planes of the city.
This submerged space is animated as place, as an environment
of
scale within which there exists a cruciality and intensity of
flows, actions, and affects. As such, these mediators are
perhaps the
most ecologically aware agents of which I am aware?and for a
variety of difficult and differential reasons.
I suggest that urban communities ought to reconceive
the kinds of spaces and places associated, enabled, and actualized
by this kind of scarce economic but ecological potential; that is,
beyond the implication of metaphor and descriptive language.
There is pragmatic value in literally approaching problems of
marginalized people and networks in the paradigmatic terms of
ecology. These networks, environments, and zones?animated
by the mediators' inherent practices?conjoin as a meaningful
assembly, which can challenge depoliticized and common-sense
notions about the issues facing those identified as lacking in
relation to the ecologically-problematic magnitude and overdevelopment
of hegemonic and normative everyday environments.
|
|
|
3. |
Erasure Through Aesthetics:
Gentrification and the Remaking of Space
Ryan Bigge,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson
Universities |
While gentrification is often theorized as an economic
process, my recent examination of the initial overtures of gentrification in Toronto's Little Portugal has revealed a new discourse
involving the aesthetics of contested space. Smith, Teixeira and
Caulfield, among many others, offer valuable insights into thesocial and political ramifications of gentrification. However,
terms such as "urban frontier" or "evolving neighbourhood"
suggest that the transformation of space through gentrification
is as much a discursive procedure as it is a physical alteration.
Through a combination of approaches that harness visuality
studies, Auge's non-places, and a discourse analysis of Toronto
newspapers, I will illuminate how urbanites learn to ignore or
erase particular configurations of the aging cityscape (and with
it, specific expressions of ethnicity) and valorize newer iterations
of the built environment.
Unlike classic modernist definitions that incorporate the
mixture of past and present (as first articulated by Baudelaire),
the new cosmopolitanism is defined primarily through sleek,
fresh surfaces. Here, power coalesces around those cultural intermediaries (such as journalists) able to generate discourses
of erasure, along with designers, architects and entrepreneurs
who develop and enact "appropriate" urban aesthetics. Using a
specific subset of Toronto's Little Portugal as a case study, my
paper will explore how the "normative semiotics of space," the
introduction of an urban fabric constituted by seamlessness and
a "homogeneity of aesthetic encodings which endow space with
pre-ordained meaning" act to discursively disappear portions of
the city, even as theirmateriality remains substantially unaltered
(Edensor 2005).
|
|
10:30 am |
Lost in Transition:
Borders, Surfaces and Translation
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Michael Prokopow |
|
1. |
Maps of the Smart Border
Aaron Gordon,
Department of Art History and
Communication Studies, McGill University |
My paper considers the relationship between national identity and a Canadian erritoriality imagined through maps
and modern cartography. Specifically, I explore the borders of
the state and boundaries of national belonging in an attempt to
displace the colonial "fixity" of Canadian identities.
In a globalizing world where
borders are made more porous for purposes of multinational
trade and investment, there
is an unprecedented effort by affluent nation-states to build new
borders to stem the flows of migrants coming from the "global
south" to their countries. Less "fixed" territorially,
these mobile checkpoints are constructed in-and-outside the state's
borders
with new technologies. With its new biometric, identification
devices, the Canada-US "Smart Border" policy is one
such border. And yet, although it is a time when Canada's borders
are
in flux, the nationalist narratives written about and against
a Canadian-American border continue to overlap Canadian identity
and territoriality, and delineate a national, imagined community
with natural and relatively static boundaries. These boundary
narratives police the limits of "Canadianness" and
continually re-fix and put it in-place. Maps and cartographic
techniques are
essential components in this process of national identification.
Drawing heavily on cultural geographers
like Thongchai Winichak ul and his idea of the geo-body, and
Homi Bhabha's
idea of the stereotype, I will investigate the racial and cultural
limits of a mapped Canada that perpetuates "fixed" national
identities and privileges the white unmarked body. I will also
consider how these identities might be displaced by exploring
Avtar Brah's notion of "diaspora space," and reconsider
Canadian identities according to cartographies that resist
stasis and imagine "home" and "belonging" as
spaces that are always, already mobile.
|
|
|
2. |
The Depth of Skin:
A Study of Surface-play in Contemporary Architecture
S. Yahya Islami,
Department of Arts, Culture and
Environment, University of Edinburgh |
Semper rejected the view which prioritized structure
over ornamentation and colour, replacing it with one in which
surface-play became important. In this way, he provoked an
understanding of architecture as taking place at the front, on the
face, and on the sur-face of structures. He advocated the use of
colour and pattern as the joy of architectural creation.
New digital technologies have brought about a continuation
of the Semperian delight in the surface. E-paper, digital
screens, printed concrete, composite polymers and dynamic
cladding systems, allow us to relish our appreciation of architecture
at the surface level. The greater interaction of architecture
with the digital media has allowed for a return to the playful use
of colour, light and pattern in architecture, which bears great resemblance to the carpets and decorative tileworks of the Near
East, which inspired Semper and his contemporaries in the
nineteenth century. There seems to be a return to surface-play
and colour in the twenty first century and ornamentation has
acquired a new, more dynamic character.
Thus, surface in contemporary architecture is becoming
more than superficial: it is becoming surficial. What has
become of great importance is an interdisciplinary appreciation
of architecture and the acknowledgment of surfaces as bearers of
meaning, and as places for communication and exchange.
What follows is an investigation into the blurring effect
of new technologies on traditional surface/structure dichotomies
followed by different architectural projects which embody such
ideas.
|
|
|
3. |
TBA |
CANCELLED:
Unfolding
of Language: The Productive Tension of Translation
Natalia A. Mikhailova, Department of Comparative Literature, SUNY-Buffalo
|
|
|
|
|
ADJUNCT
WORKSHOP: "POLITICS, POLICY, COMMUNICATION & CULTURE"
By the Toronto Universities Policy Discussion Group
(TUPDiG) |
1:30 pm |
Internationalization
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Kevin Dowler |
|
1. |
The Operationalization of Civil Society:
The Canadian International Development Agency
(CIDA) and the Associational Terrain of Democracy
Roy Bendor,
School of Communication, Simon Fraser
University |
Recent shifts in international development policy have
increasingly focused on linking economic and political restructuring
under the panoply of "good governance." These new
modes of political conditionality foreground civil society as a
source of legitimacy and popular support for the twin neo-liberal
thrusts of democratization and marketization, embodying what
some critics call the "new development orthodoxy."
The political conditionality trend did not pass over
CIDA, whose latest policy statements emphasize the need to
engage civil society in development programs through consultative
processes and responsive programming. However, the
specific form and function civil society assumes in CIDA policy
raise questions as to the viability of premising "aid effectiveness"
(in CIDA's terms) in a democratic transformation propelled by
civil society.
Employing critical discourse analysis with a focus on
policy coherence, this presentation explores CIDA's approach to
civil society as networks of non-governmental organizations and
associations, locates different formulations of civil society on the
range that stretches between nominal and participatory models
of democracy, and draws attention to the complexities and
problematic inherent to the discursive use of civil society. The
conceptual analysis points to the ideological contexts in which
civil society is used in both descriptive and prescriptive manners,
and which result in its reduced analytical usefulness.
|
|
|
2. |
U.S. Cultural Policy as/and U.S. Foreign Policy
Tanner Mirrlees,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson
Universities |
Critical discourses of U.S. cultural imperialism have
been problematized over the past twenty years and often replaced
by discourses of post-national cultural globalization. The
blindspot in both discourses is an account of the U.S. cultural
foreign policies and state-supported communicational and informational
apparatuses that articulated, distributed and sought to
win international consent to "American culture" for much of the
20th century.
To illuminate this blindspot,
this paper historicizes the deployment of culture as a U.S.
foreign policy resource in
U.S. foreign policy discourse and practice from 1930 to the
present. By accounting for the state-financed communicational
and informational policies and apparatuses that articulated
and circulated American culture around the world, this paper
updates
theoretical considerations of U.S. cultural imperialism and
provides a counterpoint to post-national and stateless theories
of cultural globalization. A critical and historicist analysis
of U.S.
cultural policy as/and U.S foreign policy is crucial if scholars
of both cultural studies and political-economy want to understand
the 20th century construction and expansion of the U.S. empire
and its current cultural war in the Middle East.
|
|
|
3. |
Framing the Public Mind: Strategic Language, Framing
and the Invasion of Iraq
David Clifton,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson Universities |
The Bush Administration's use of language during the
2003 invasion of Iraq was an attempt to control public discourse,
and through it, public opinion. Words and phrases such
as weapons of mass destruction, regime change and coalitionof the willing were designed to rally a global public consensus
behind the war, and extend the goodwill that many western
nations offered the U.S. after the September 11, 2001 attacks.
Political actors use strategic language to create discursive
"frames". These frames are heuristic devices that selectively
highlight elements of political messages to promote particular
problem definitions, causal interpretations and moral judgments.
Politicians use strategic words and phrases in the hope
that journalists will adopt their language uncritically. When
journalists treat politicized language as common parlance, they
both exempt it from scrutiny and lend credibility to the arguments
and biases embedded in that language.
The Bush Administration's use of strategic language
was pernicious not because it made for successful propaganda,
but because it frustrated intelligent public discourse and polarized
public opinion. Strategic language has important implications
for democratic communication. Even if audiences are not
easily manipulated, the uncritical use and repetition of strategic
words and phrases undermines the quality of public debate, and
contributes to political alienation and cynicism.
Using a content analysis of 212 White House,
Pentagon and U.S. State Department transcripts from the first
46 days of the invasion, this paper is examines the use of 406
"ideologically ladened" words and phrases as speculates as to their
impact on public discourse.
|
|
2:45 pm |
Identity Politics and Policies
Panel Chairperson:
Dr. Amin Alhassan
|
|
1. |
Outlining the Need for an Interdisciplinary Discourse
Analysis of Poverty Coverage in Canada
Joanna Redden,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson
Universities |
This paper represents the first stage of a research project
in progress. The paper points to the need for a discourse analysis
of poverty coverage in Canada and outlines why such a study
should take an interdisciplinary approach. In the process the
paper highlights a major policy gap in Canada, points to the
need for further research, and speaks to the benefits of an
interdisciplinary approach in media and policy studies.
Poverty and the increasing economic inequality in
Canada are arguably the most pressing issues facing the nation
today. Yet, there is little public discussion within the mainstream
media about potential solutions. In fact, a number of social
theorists including Herbert J. Gans, Michael B. Katz and
Zygmunt Bauman have argued that poverty issues are regularly
mystified in mainstream media coverage and that the poor are
stereotypically portrayed as "others," dangerous, and/or dependent.
This negative coverage, each argues, affects what we choose
to do or not do about poverty.
Over the last decade much empirical work has examined
the media's stereotypical coverage of poverty issues in the United
States and the damaging consequences, but little work has been
done in Canada to examine how the poor are being portrayed
and how such portrayals might be influencing public opinion,
and in turn public policy.
To analyze the mutually constitutive relationships that
comprise the social fabric of news and audience this research
paper presents the necessity and benefits of an interdisciplinary
approach to media and policy studies. The paper asserts that a
discourse analysis of poverty coverage must be rooted in Political Economy, and employ Cultural studies and discourse analysis.
Further, it argues that recent agenda-setting and attribute-setting
research illustrates that the media do have the ability to influence
what issues we think about and how we think about those
issues.
|
|
|
2. |
The Network as a Resolution to the Refugee Problem:
Towards a Theory of an Alternative Understanding of
the Refugee
Stephanie Silverman,
Political Science, York University |
The refugee is situated as the outsider in the inside/outside
divide that results from the delineation of nation-states.
Often securitized as a threat to the stability of the domestic
community, the refugee's stateless position calls into question
many tenets of sovereignty, citizenship, language and politics.
Theoretically and often practically, the refugee is rendered
voiceless and so is unable to function as a political actor. It is
not impossible, however, to imagine a solution to this situation
which is commonly known as "the refugee problem". What is
proposed is a recovery of agency and identity through networking
to limit the authority of traditional state-based sovereignty,
and theoretically free the refugee from their secondary positions
in the inside/outside dialectic.
A "network" is here appreciated as a vision of the political
that resists the hegemony of the territorialization of identity
in order to express a new articulation of community. Following
the ideas of RBJ Walker, Michael Dillon, Peter Mandaville,
Cynthia Weber and others, this articulation points to a dynamic
"translocal" actor or political site that is powerful enough to
transgress borders and is continually being reconstituted through
the political act of meaning creation.
Inspiration for this idea was
drawn from the Guatemalan refugee return movement of the early
1990s. The network of
committees that sprung from the Mexican camps in these years
defied the traditional "victim" images associated
with displaced people, and provided stimulation for both theorists
and other
refugee groups around the world. Nevertheless, the point of
discussion remains: Does a theory inspired by this practice
reflect real life, or is a resolution to the paradox of the "refugee
problem" destined to remain purely conceptual?
|
|
|
3. |
Go Directly Online, Do not Pass
"Emerg": Seeing the Social Construction of Health Information
Websites Through Policy
Karen Smith,
School of Communication, Simon Fraser
University |
In the summer of 2005, I completed an action research
project, assisting, observing and interviewing patients in the
waiting room of the Mid-Main Community Health Center as
an Internet terminal was introduced. Mid-Main is an innovative,
non-profit primary healthcare center located in Vancouver,
British Columbia (BC). The computer at Mid-Main was
introduced, in part, to address the digital divide disadvantages
faced by patients who are not connected to the Internet at home
to access health information. During the project, the homepage
of the browser was rotated between the BC HealthGuide,
and Canadian Health Network websites maintained by the BC
Ministry of Health Services, and the Public Health Agency of
Canada.
This paper will outline a method
utilized to conduct discourse analysis on policy pertinent
documents including press
releases, HANSARD transcripts, and government reports related
to the health information websites accessed in this study.
A social constructivist approach to discourse analysis was
applied,
due to my belief that technology is shaped by participants
and within particular social contexts. As "top-down" systems
under the Canadian connectivity strategy, government websites
are
greatly influenced by designers and decision-makers. Tensions
exist in the policy goals of the websites to reduce pressure
on the system and simultaneously empower patients with knowledge.
A range of rhetorical themes emerged from the documents
including: renewal, access, self-care, and the cross-cutting
concept of patients' needs. This paper will argue that the policy
defined goals and objectives of the BC HealthGuide, and Canadian
Health Network are important to consider in relation to
patients' experience of seeking health information online.
|
|
4:00 pm |
Advocacy and Criticism
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Colin Mooers |
|
1. |
Why did Canadian Private-Sector Cultural Policy
Advocacy Fail?: The Canadian Arts Council and the
Federal Government (1945-58)
Gregory Klages,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson Universities |
Writing regarding cultural
policy development in Canada, particularly by those involved
in the arts, has tended
to offer a celebration of the merits of federal management
and support, portraying the state's move into culture as
the result of
enlightened benevolence. This position overlooks or downplays
the significant history of alternative policy proposals by
private sector, "grass-roots" organizations that
were ignored by the federal government for over a decade
before it undertook to lead
cultural management in Canada. My doctoral research applies
several current, contested political science models developed
to explain institutional and network development to better
understand
how Canada's federal cultural policy network developed,
and in particular, why policy advocacy by private-sector groups
representing practicing artists failed to shape cultural policy
enacted by the Canadian federal government.
In 1945, representatives of sixteen private-sector Canadian
creative arts groups came together as the Canadian Arts
Council (CAC), seeking a limited slate of federal cultural policy
goals. While involved in policy consultation with the federal
government, by the late 1950s, despite superficial satisfaction
of their goals, the CAC was marginalized in the federal cultural
policy development process.
My presentation will apply several models from within
the "new institutionalism" stream of political science to archival
institutional documents from the CAC, its members, and
relevant departments of the federal government. Taken together,
the application of these models to the history of the CACs institutional and policy network development and behaviour
strongly suggest that the groups' ultimate failure was based on
three factors: the challenges of policy learning for "grass-roots"
advocates, the CACs own institutional characteristics, and the
values which compelled federal initiative in cultural activities.
|
|
|
2. |
From Communicated Boundaries to Inclusivity and
Intergenerational Solidarity: The Discourse of Adult
Perceptions of Youth
Amy Brandon,
Faculty of Education, York University |
This paper establishes a link between the development of Canadia
broadcasting policy and the Canadian English-language
independent production film and television unions. Using the
unions' policy interventions around the Canadian Radio-television
and Telecommunications Commission's 1999 Television
Policy and the decline in Canadian dramatic programming as a
case study, the paper examines how broadcasting policy shapes
domestic industry labour market conditions and how labour
intervenes in the policy process as representatives of their members'
interests. I argue that labour's adoption of a coalition
framework with the formation of the Coalition of Canadian
Audio-visual Unions has positively impacted labour's power and
efficacy in the Canadian broadcasting policy sphere.
|
|
|
3. |
In Search of the Knockout:
The Media's Fixation with Competitive Communication
in Canadian Federal Election Debates
J.P. Lewis,
Department of Political Science,
Carleton University |
During the 1988 Canadian federal election debate,
Liberal leader John Turner gave an enthusiastic performance
in deriding Prime Minister Brian Mulroney over the policy of
free trade with the United States. Turner aggressively attackedMulroney with the memorable accusation that the Progressive
Conservatives were attempting to sell out Canada with "one
signature of a pen". This exchange followed the famous so-called
"knock-out punch" of Mulroney against Turner four years earlier
over Liberal patronage appointments with the assertion that
Turner "had an option". There have been gaffes and poor performances,
but no post-1988 debate participant has enjoyed the
pleasure of receiving the media praise Mulroney or Turner have
experienced.
This paper will present the thesis that the political media
and political pundits should discontinue the practice of seeking
out the winning line or "knock-out punch". In the five election
campaigns since 1988, the media has not acknowledged the
delivery of a "you had an option sir" line. No leader has been
credited with that kind of performance and the obsession with
the debates of 1980s does not seen to be fading anytime soon.
Through a deep analysis of the newspaper media coverage of the
Canadian federal election debates the paper will demonstrate
that the political media elite has created expectations and raised
the bar for debate performance that leaders cannot meet. This
study will demonstrate how the press in Canada has created a
scenario in which debates will continue to be seen as "draws",
"close contests" or containing "no knock-out punches".
|
|
|
Sunday March 26
9:30 am |
Spatial Orbits: Ever (R)evolving Personal
Spaces and their Outer Effects
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Jennifer Vanderburgh |
|
1. |
From Affectation to Affect: Thinking Corporeal
Susceptibilities in the Cultural Surround
John Hunting,
Department of Art History and
Communication Studies, McGill University |
This paper argues that the "spatial turn" in cultural
studies ought to acknowledge the body itself not only as a site
of differentiation (i.e., of affectation and style) but as a site of
vulnerability and need. In this regard Emmanuel Levinas has
theorized the positionality of the body as a radical susceptibility.
To be sure "geographies" or material sites of culture and communication
articulate the "manuscripts" or "mattering maps" that
situate the look, behavior, intentionalities and affectations of
bodies in a nexus of cultural values and expectations. In fact the
body itself is a kind of socio-psychological terrain wherein manners
of being, personal styles (indeed personality) are produced
and reproduced in material/corporeal terms. As such bodies are
not only the locale for social performances that are site specific,
they are also locales for the deployment of vital energies and
intentionalities that pattern the range and dynamism of things
like body movement and voice in predictable ways. Hence if
cultural geographies evidence a certain "texture" or "feel", the
personalities of others also evidence an affective propensity that
is similarly felt. But if the body can be understood as a cultural
"site" in its own right, it is important to theorize the body not
only as the site of cultural and personal transformation, it is also
the site of an elemental susceptibility, enjoyment and suffering.
To be "affected", then, would have this double meaning. On the
one hand as the dynamic deployment of manners and styles, in
many ways traversed by and fitted into the cultural surround
and, on the other, as a vitalizing contact, proximity and invigoration.
Indeed from the point of view of a Levinasian theory of embodied susceptibility, affect, in this regard, is irreducible to
the specific deployments of affect and style we associate with
social performance, it also signals the intrinsic value of feeling
that manners and styles both sponsor and constrain.
|
|
|
2. |
MySpace.com: Exploring Online Music Spaces
Jeremy Morris,
Department of Art History and
Communication Studies, McGill University |
From internet audio streams to downloads to musical
ring tones, new digital technologies and new cultural practices
are facilitating changes to the way music is marketed, distributed
and consumed. New outlets for the exchange (e.g. myspace.
com) and sale (e.g. iTunes, Puretracks) of music are evolving
and creating markets where none existed before. Internet service
providers, not previously considered players in the music business,
are now central points for the discovery and distribution of
our favourite songs. Be it on cell phones, iPod's or the internet,
the business of music is changing as novel spaces surface.
As a distribution outlet, advertising model and web
destination, the music subsection of myspace.com (2006) is
emerging as an important marketing and distribution tool for
musicians of various genres, be they independent or mainstream
artists. Boasting over 27 million users (Brandweek 2005),
myspace.com was originally conceived as a kind of Napstermeets-
Friendster website. It has since blossomed into a community
where users gather to exchange music and ideas about
music. It is also a site where commercial interests rub up uncomfortably
against artists seeking alternative ways of independently
producing and distributing their music. In this light, myspace
reveals itself as a site for music, a site for commerce, a social
network for musicians and fans, and a space for interaction.
Myspace.com is not simply an emerging site for the
circulation of music; it is transforming the traditional landscape
upon which artists market/share their products and upon which audiences discover music. As the music industry struggles to
understand and react to the implications of the mp3 revolution,
this exploratory paper analyzes myspace.com as both a
web site and a social space for the marketing, distribution and
consumption of music. Drawing on Bodker's (2004) ideas about
the changing materiality of music, this paper also questions the
impact of treating music as a digitized commodity.
|
|
|
3. |
Reclaiming the Past:
Transforming the Scapes of Schizophrenia
Susanne Cardwell,
Department of Communication,
University of Calgary |
The technologically
mediated versions of discourses on schizophrenia are contestable
forms of social control. Through
a five-minute multimedia performance, featuring live dance,
graphic artwork, and music with voice over, I will issue multiple
layers of simultaneously interacting themes of 'transforming
scapes' in media and culture regarding schizophrenia. This
advocacy/creative work will be followed by a discussion.
First, I will show the transformation of the scape of
theory. In doing so, I will highlight the necessity of evaluating
schizophrenia from a critical erspective rather than a postmodernist
stream of thought. This transformation is presented
as necessary for emancipatory change and the redefining of the
media scapes that have stereotypically portrayed schizophrenia.
Second, I will show the transformation of the scape of liberation,
from disenfranchisement into powerfulness, through my dance
piece. A memorable aspect of this performance is that I am a
woman with schizophrenia who is undergoing a similar transformation
through academia.
Lastly, I will show a transformation of the media scape
itself as an overlapping of the themes of entrapment versus
release, with negative versus positive representations. The latter
theme will revisit how early history held people with schizophrenia in high esteem (Zilboorg cited in Rotenberg 1978: 3).
However, this has since been replaced by negative stereotypes
of schizophrenia. This presentation will revive early history's
conceptions of schizophrenia by making links with documented
prophets who heard voices from God. Furthermore, the heightened
perceptual awareness of people with schizophrenia will be
constructed as potentially evolutionary.
|
|
10:45 am |
Streetscapes:
Negotiating the Urban Environment
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Michael Murphy |
|
1. |
Faith in the Street
Charlotte Scott,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson Universities |
Faith in the Street is a 12-minute soundscape composition
based in the discursive, creative practice of soundwalking
and the study of sound ecology. The piece contemplates ideas
about faith, consumption and overlapping acoustic territories
in the modern city, and expresses the musical resonances that
emerge from an inner ear in perpetual dialogue with the acoustic
environment of everyday city life.
Acoustic ecology is a field of research and creative
practice that is finding increasing resonance with cultural
studies scholars. Sound inhabits the interstitial spaces between
constructed subjects and objects. It is experienced intellectually,
as parsed messages about the environment, but also tangibly,
as physical vibrations that pass through and around the human
body: we live in sound, and sound develops meaning within
us. The soundscapes of urban spaces have become increasingly
suffused with industrial and commercial noise, blurring the
boundaries between personal and public, sacred and commodified space. These acoustic territories merge physically in the air,
and are remixed and re-signified in the artist's imagination.
Field recordings of doomsday evangelists, missionaries, and
bible-blitzers indicate the at-first incongruous presence of faith
in modern public spaces. The evangelizing, at turns dominating
and fatherly, is offset by commercial sound pollution, bringing
the hawking of commodities and of religions into the same aural
environment. Yet, the city is an acoustic space full of potential
and often unrealized beauty, ready to be teased out of the frantic
mess of motors, pop radio and megaphone prophets, and
rewoven acoustically to reflect a more subjective interpretation
of the modern soundscape.
I profess my own faith in the street through musical
performance, realizing the city's capacity for transcendence when
re-interpreted and remixed with a critical and compassionate ear.
Thus, dual and perhaps oppositional meanings of transcendence
inhabit the same acoustic space. This composition reflects both
the physical experience of soundwalking in urban territories, and
the imagined and emotionally-constructed territories invented
through subjective imagination and a desire for meaningful
engagement with the modern acoustic environment.
|
|
|
2. |
The 'Car(e)less Driving' Incident:
Elementary Exercises in Auto-Intervention
Chris Smith,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson Universities |
As both a performative style of creative, artistic practice
and a mode of political action that critiques the form and
function of the contemporary capitalist cityscape, the emerging
practice of "urban intervention" seeks to inter/dis-rupt and
directly intervene in the conditioned, taken-for-granted patterns
of everyday life in the urban environment.
Tracing the work of a small artist/activist
collective that formed out of a course being offered through
Toronto's
Anarchist Free University, this creative work and accompanying
artist/activist talk will critically examine the issues involved
in the practice of 'urban intervention' through one recent, local,
Toronto-based example: the Free Parking Space project.
In April 2005, the Pedestrian Mob collective began
constructing car-sized model frameworks out of recycled cardboard
fabric rolls. Secured by duct tape and a series of straps, the
models were designed to be worn by an individual pedestrian,
either walking or cycling. After the wildly positive reactions the
group received from their first performative interventions in the
Kensington Market area, they began taking the Free Parking
Space model into different parts of the city and documenting their experiences.
Within weeks the project began receiving critical
attention from the media and the public alike, with articles
appearing in Does, Eye, Now, and the Globe and Mail. Before
long, however, the group also began to attract attention from the
Toronto police, and in June 2005, two members of the project
were targeted while wearing the models and charged with "careless
driving". Still pending trial, this has become known as the
"car(e)less driving" incident.
Tracing this autonomous, anarchist-inspired example
of auto-intervention from inception to conclusion, this talk
will address the wide spectrum of anti-car critiques which were
spawned by the Free Parking Space project?what the Globe
and Mail called a "vehicle for dissent"? in the context of the
larger politics of urban intervention as an emergent political/poetic,
critical/creative, artist/activist practice.
|
|
|
3. |
Between Exploitation and Play:
Skateboarding and the Negotiation of Resistance
Jason Phillips,
Department of English and Film Studies,
Wilfred Laurier University |
My paper addresses the question "What potential exists for
scapes of resistance, or opportunities to challenge present
boundaries and structures?" I assert that skateboarding is a fluid
scape ? a horizontally arranged form of negotiated resistance
that challenges and re-signifies the functional meaning of urban
design.
I argue that skateboarding inhabits a fluid, negotiated
socio-cultural position in-between commercial exploitation and
a perceived authenticity as an act of play, of freedom and selfexpression.
Skateboarders negotiate subject positions between
these two poles, and that negotiation is a form of resistance that
shifts between modes of implicit and explicit activism.
I demonstrate the different modes of resistance by examining three short video clips of skateboarding activity in
downtown Toronto. The first clip (3 minutes, 34 seconds)
presents skateboarding as an implicit act of resistance that
seeks to re-signify the meaning of urban space through the
act of skateboarding as play. The second clip (2 minutes, 33
seconds) demonstrates a more explicit mode of resistance as the
skateboarders engage with security personnel in an urban space
functionally designed to facilitate commercial activity. The third
clip (4 minutes, 53 seconds) is footage of explicit acts of resistance
by young people who, through the act of skateboarding,
are trying to establish public space in a corporately privatized
urban environment.
In specific relevance to the themes of the conference, I
discuss the communicative modes by which such acts are organized
and the results skateboarding-as-resistance has achieved in
changing both the conceptual and physical landscapes of urban
environments.
|
|
1:45 pm |
Where do you want to go Today?:
Tourism, Technology and Transformation
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Ed Slopek |
|
1. |
Destination Place Identity and Tourism Advertising
Imagery: Place Images in Caribbean Destination
Advertisements
Susan Dupej,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson
Universities |
In an increasingly complex and global marketplace,
tourists have a rapidly growing, boundless range of varied
tourism products and destination options from which to
choose. In order to combat challenges of increased competition
among the growing number of available and accessible tourism
sites, destinations have engaged in advertising to develop
comprehensive place identity programs in efforts to differentiate
themselves and to emphasize the uniqueness of their tourism
product. The proposed academic paper presentation is to present
the results and implications of an empirical study that examined
the representation and portrayal of place in tourism destination
advertisements by investigating the relationship between
destination place identity and tourism advertising imagery.
Using a case study of travel magazine advertisements promoting
similar types of destinations in the Caribbean region, the study
demonstrates the ineffectiveness of tourism advertisements in
portraying a discernable place identity, largely a function of the
type and quality of place-specific and non-place specific images
contained in the tourism advertisement.
The implications of these findings in terms of place and
space relate closely to the theme of "Emerging Spaces, Transforming
Scopes". The way in which destinations are represented
not only raise questions over the claimed importance of distinctive
place identity, but also over the changing way in which place
is imagined in relation to tourism. Tourism is essentially a placebased
phenomenon that relies on the projection of place identity
to attract tourists. Ironically, tourism advertising, with its use of similar non-place specific images, influences a dilution of established
destinations; blurring identities, erasing boundaries, and
homogenizing spaces. Increasingly separated from the historically
rooted and physically bounded entities of geographic space,
new notions of place, resulting from its commodification as a
mass produced product for tourist consumption, has challenged
present national boundaries with an emerging imagined space of
no definite characteristics, no fixed boarders and no meaningful boundaries. The effect has been a rendering of places that are
indistinguishable, interchangeable and easily substituted for one
another, and thus, transforming the way we look at the world.
|
|
|
2. |
Surfing under Palm Trees: The Internet and Everyday
Life in Barbados
Samantha Moonsammy,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson
Universities |
This article reports the findings of an ethnographic study
of internet use conducted in Barbados. The goal was to analyze
the Internet in everyday life. It examines in detail the effects of
the Internet, focus on the types of activities performed online,
and explore how these fit into the complexity of everyday life.
Studying the Internet in Barbados will address questions such as
the significance of the Internet in the home and users relationships
with and connections to imagined and physical spaces.
The questions I address are: by what processes can and
do Barbadians maintain cultural connections to place via the internet.
Furthermore, focus was placed on what Barbadians find
in the internet, what they make of it and how they can relate its
possibilities to themselves and their futures. The findings could
reveal a great deal about both the relationship between technology
and identity in a Barbadian context.
I set out to identify and explore the process by which
"the user" becomes an active and significant figure in the social
shaping of the internet (see Bakardjieva and Smith 2001). The "user" here refers to Barbadians who are domestic users and have
access to the internet in their home. The rationale for this study
begins with an examination of the research conducted by two
British scholars Daniel Miller and Don Slater in 2000. They
conducted one of the first ethnographic studies on the internet
in Trinidad. Their rich analysis illustrates how the internet is
increasingly shaping, and being shaped by users' lives. One
of their significant findings includes a detailed account of the
complex integration between on-line and off-line worlds.
The notion of virtuality has played a key role in previous
social research on the Internet. The term suggests that media
can provide both means of interaction and modes of representation
that add up to "spaces" or "places" that participants can treat
as if they were real (Miller and Slater 2000: 4). My ethnographic
research begins with the assumption that the notion of cyberspace
is not a place apart from offline life. Rather than starting
from virtuality, I am interested in starting the investigation of
the Internet from within the complex ethnographic experience.
The method of data collection included ethnographic interviews
of 32 users from ten households in the same neighbourhood.
|
|
|
3. |
TBA |
CANCELLED:
Intersection
of Social Classes and Gender Relations:
A Case Study on the Socio-Cultural Domestication of Mobile Phone in Port-au-Prince
Margareth Cormier,
Department of Communication, University of Ottawa |
|
3:00 pm |
tranSfOrMAtions
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Janine Marchessault |
|
1. |
Seeing and Experiencing Chouinard:
The Body Language of the Spectator
Kate Cornell,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson
Universities |
In Revolution in Poetic Language, Julia Kristeva posits
the chora as analogous to vocal and kinetic rhythms of the body.
As an audience member who also trained as a dancer, I find my
body responds instantaneously and rhythmically to dance performances,
thereby connecting to the chora. The act of writing
becomes a physical manifestation of the theatrical experience.
My research questions include: what role does the body play in
the transmission of dance to language? How is the essence of
the chora transferred from dancer to spectator in the experience
of watching a performance?
The writings of Julia Kristeva, Roland Barthes and
John Martin provide important theories of the body that aid in
answering these research questions. Kristeva's theories regarding
the importance of the body to language are particularly applicable
to this examination. Furthermore, Roland Barthes' terms
geno-song and pheno-song apply Kristeva's concepts because
these concrete terms offer functional examples of the semiotic
and symbolic in action. Finally, John Martin's term metakinesis,
the transference of energy between the dancer and spectator,
connects dance to Kristeva's chora. With an awareness of the
chora in each subject, I want to examine the transfer of the
chora from the dancer to the spectator and its impact on writing
in the work of Montreal choreographer Marie Chouinard,
specifically the male solo Des feux dans la nuit.
|
|
|
2. |
Reworking the Desirous Gaze:
Self Constructed Eros in Cinema
Shana MacDonald,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson
Universities |
The paper I am proposing examines the questions that
arise when a female filmmaker crafts her own erotic image
outside the dominant practices of commercial film and porn.
Considering the long trajectory of erotic cinema made by
women, with a specific focus on the films and performances
of Carolee Schneemann alongside the debates started within
feminist psychoanalytic film theory in the mid-1970s, I will
discuss the importance of considering erotic self-portraiture as
a key feminist act in cinema and art. I will draw out the ways
in which erotic representation of oneself can actively position
the artists' body not as "sex object, but as a willed, erotic
subject commanding her own image" (1). The paper aims to
challenge and re-think not only the representation of women
in the dominant political economy of Hollywood and commercial
pornography but also wishes to challenge the monolithic
position imposed on feminist film theory since the 1970s in
regards to the active male gaze and the passive female subject.
Through an exploration of Carolee Schneemann's 1967 Fuses
in dialogue with my recent film self seeking frenzy (which draws
great inspiration from the former) I will argue how through the
unique position of the female artist deriving pleasure from the
creation of her own erotic form many of the restrictions imposed
by both mainstream visual culture and the institutionalization
of certain methods of feminist thought can be challenged and
worked through allowing a space for feminist art to move past
the tension that Carolee Schneemann describes as being "permitted to be an image but not an image-maker creating her own self
image" (2). The paper will be accompanied by a short clip from
Fuses as well as a longer clip from self seeking frenzy.
|
|
|
3. |
The Twists, Turns and Torsions of (Re)volt
Izabella Pruska-Oldenhof,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson Universities |
This paper
will investigate the notion of "revolt," and
more specifically what does this term mean to us today, how
has its meaning changed over time, and what is its function
in culture and in art. By concentrating primarily on Julia
Kristeva's
philosophical writings on this topic, this paper will begin
by providing a rough overview of the current meaning of revolt
and its practice, or non-practice. It will subsequently delineate
the etymological evolution of this term and its semantic
shifts
or what Kristeva calls its "plasticity," which
she insists is dependent on the historical context. Taking
this notion of plasticity,
which also implies mobility and activity, this paper will
discuss Kristeva's notion of "the semiotic" modality
of language and its indebtedness to Sigmund Freud's theory
of the primary process
thinking and the unconscious. This Freudian shift will help
to also illustrate one of the most fundamental qualities
and meaning of "revolt" that persisted throughout
its etymological evolution, the notion of a backward movement
or return. This
regressive movement into an earlier state is crucial to both
Kristeva's conception of "the semiotic" and what
she insists is the foundation of "revolt," the
pre-linguistic and somatically oriented state of our existence
(the ntrauterine,
the infantile
stages and the archaic). She contends that poetic language, in
particular the texts of the avant-garde poets such us Mallarme,
Artaud and Joyce, by means of its close affinity with "the
semiotic" modality, through its emphasis on rhythm rather
than denotation or representation, "reminds us of its eternal
function:
to introduce through the symbolic that which works on, moves
through, and threatens it. The theory of the unconscious seeks
the very thing that poetic language practices within and against
the social order: the ultimate means for its transformation or
subversion, the precondition for its survival and revolution"
(3).
By drawing on Kristeva's notions of "the semiotic" and "revolt" this paper will discuss how both concepts can be applied
to cinematic practices, as a way to challenge the dominant
modes of representation imposed by the capitalist institutions
and economic system of entertainment. It will conclude with a
brief discussion and a screening of a film created by me, titled
her carnal ongings, which will demonstrate the exploration of
"the semiotic" modality in cinema and hopefully the intimations
of "revolt."
|
|
|
4. |
What Light Through Yonder Filmstrip Breaks?
Towards an Interdisciplinary Approach to the Semiotics
of Cinema:
A Case Study of Stan Brakhage's Black Ice
Kelly Egan,
Joint Graduate Programme in
Communication and Culture, York and Ryerson Universities |
For a film's audience, the "object" is displaced; the audience
is lacking a direct relationship to the representamen---the
filmstrip. In the context of experimental film, the filmmaker
has very material/bodily connection to the filmstrip. Often,
the filmmaker's hand is felt hen viewing the film, returning the
viewer to the originary object of analysis, back to the filmstrip.
Not surprisingly, this re-placement can affect the viewer's
understanding to the projected image, shocking the viewer into
a holistic experience of the "film." In this presentation I will
explore this perceptual process of signification in experimental
film through the application of Julia Kristeva's theory of significance on Stan Brakhage's visceral masterpiece "Black Ice." The
shattering decentredness, eclipsing of the ground-figure relationship,
emotive power and critical tension (between what I will
argue are re-presentations of the sex drive and the death drive)
have fuelled my interest in this film. By presenting "Black Ice,"
analyzing the text, and then allow the audience to re-experience
the film as my conclusion, I hope bring greater understanding
of how and why experimental film means.
|
|
4:15 pm |
Consuming Territories: Ecologies and
Economies of Popular Culture
Panel Chairperson: Dr. Steve Bailey |
|
1. |
The Circuit of Labour and Leisure in the Age of
Biopolitical Production
Scott Stoneman & Max Haiven,
Department of English
and Cultural Studies, McMaster University |
Adorno writes that the "lack of imagination which is
cultivated and inculcated by society renders people helpless
in their free time" intimating the question of time as the last
conquest of sovereign power over life, the complete occupation
of the possibility of improvisation or imagination by preoccupation,
the limit of which is idiomatically characterized by that
deceptively banal phrase "killing time." What does it mean that
the temporalities of occupation and preoccupation increasingly
appear inextricable in an era of globalization.
Our paper seeks a clearer understanding of the relationship
between immaterial labour, what is today increasingly taken
to be the dominant modality of "work time," and what we still
tend to regard as "free time": leisure under late capitalism. We
bring into proximity two projects--Adorno's and that of Michael
Hardt and Antonio Negri--in the interest of considering what it
might mean today for power to smuggle an increasingly "immaterial"
labour into leisure. We posit that such a turn means
the making properly biopolitical of work-time oriented towards
the production of life in the modality of docile preoccupation,
which is felt, of course and crucially, to be self-willed. What is
it about the field of possible position-takings which ensures the
"direct" production of social relations. The condition of contemporary
temporal privation, and of increasing atomization,
are strategies of capitalist sovereignty which sustain themselves
in spite of profound popular ennui by rendering free time
"helpless," by denying systematically--through in part the very
organization of space in, for example (and example par excellence), a Wal-Mart--the experience of pleasure through freedom
and collective action.
We are centrally concerned with how the "conquest of
happiness," which characterizes the temporal dimensionality of
a globe labouring under biopolitical production, can be rearticulated
and reappropriated for a politics of hope which aspires
to begin to undo the evacuation of imagination and yearns to
affirm the latent but identifiable desire for solidarity and selfgovernance.
|
|
|
2. |
Consuming Currency: Gold Farming, Alienation, and the Consumption of Virtual Goods Between Online and
Offline Environments
Jennifer Martin,
Faculty of Information and Media
Studies, University of Western Ontario |
Within visually-oriented online games, limits on character
appearance and attributes can cause people to be less than
pleased with their virtual experience. In these spaces, virtual
currency and the virtual goods that can be purchased with it are
imbued with power. Through the purchase of goods, facilitated
by currency, players can change their clothing and other goods
that they possess, simultaneously changing their attributes and
appearance. In order to facilitate these purchases, many players
resort to using "real" offline money to purchase virtual currency.
In recent years, there has been significant growth in a practice
termed "gold farming" in which individuals and companies
enter into online games, gather virtual currency, and sell it to
players for offline money.
This paper details the crossing of the borders between
virtual spaces and offline life in terms of the practice of gold
farming and the purchase of virtual currency and goods. Although
such purchases can lead to benefits for players, there are
significant issues surrounding the currency production of ingame
farmers. It will be seen that in producing virtual currency, workers are engaging in practices surrounding virtual consumption
that are linked to offline alienation from their means of
production and from other individuals. Despite the apparent
separation between virtual and offline spaces, virtual currency
serves as a means not only of crossing the borders between the
two, but of significantly affecting individuals' experiences within
both worlds in both positive and negative ways.
|
|
|
3. |
Girls Gone Wild/Raunch: The Patriarchal and
Consumeristic Relations of an Adolescent Sub-Culture
Naomi Nichols,
Graduate Program in Education, York
University |
In this paper, I investigate a media and pop-culture
version of female adolescent sexuality. Drawing on Judith
Timson's 2005 Maclean's cover article ("The female chauvinist
pig: how it became cool to treat yourself like a piece of meat")
and the movie Girl Power: Girls Gone Wild, Volume 7, I explore
a female adolescent subculture (Clarke et al., 1976) as it is
portrayed in the media depiction of the "female chauvinist pig,"
as well as how it is consumed through the popular culture video
phenomena Girls Gone Wild. "The female chauvinist pig" is a
term coined by April Levy in her book, The Female Chauvinist
Pig: Women and the Rise of Raunch Culture and is the inspiration
for Timson's article. Throughout my investigation I draw
on Foucault's (1994) and Lesko's (2001) theoretical discussions
of Bentham's panopticon and the social organization of power,
and Lesko's (2001) exploration of adolescence as an administrative
technology.
I entered into this study intending to illuminate how a
young female subculture enacts power through explicit sexuality.
Youthful female sexuality is a hot commercial commodity
(prominent in an influx of teen/young adult pop-star personas
and an age-defying cosmetic culture geared towards adult
women), but we are critical of its presence at our own dinner
tables, in our classrooms, malls, etc. I suspected I would see the young women we commercialize and criticize in the same breath
throwing our objectifying stares back in our faces by taking ownership
of their sexuality. However, as I embarked on a journey
into the world of girls gone wild, I was shown a much more
complex picture. In this paper, I argue that the "girls gone wild"
are produced and consumed in the context of North American
culture at large, but that their performance are directed by, and
for, a ubiquitous male gaze.
|
|
|
|
|
|