Indigenous Peoples and Archaeology: From Conflict to Coalition. Anth 3510, Sept - Dec 2005. Dr. Kathryn Denning

17 Oct 2005

Back to main 3510 page.

 


 

Plan for the day

 

1  Test

2  Announcements/ organizational stuff

3  Indigenous peoples in Canadian national history - video, discussion. Video: CBC Canadian history series, episode "When the World Began", Hour 1. Scott library vid 6022.

 

 


 

Announcements / Reminders

 

1 The Centre for Academic Writing is running its courses: http://www.arts.yorku.ca/caw/mini-courses.html

 

2 Reading for today, October 17: Online reading

   
The Prehistory of Ontario  http://adamsheritage.com/pre/preont1.htm          Required: Read the Overview. Recommended: read through the individual time periods.
   
Peopling North America www.ucalgary.ca/applied_history/tutor/migrations/  

Required:

 

1. Early Migrations to the Americas (subsections 1.0 Introduction, 1.1 Problems in the Study of Early Migration, 1.2 The Spread of Homo sapiens, 1.3 Inter-Cultural Contacts)   Ensure that you read all the material within each subsection, that is, read 1.3a, 1.3b, 1.3c)

 

2. European Migrations to North America (subsections 2.0 Introduction, 2.1 The Nature of the Diaspora, 2.2 Major Influences on Migration, 2.3 Patterns in Migration and Settlement, 2.4 The Impact of Migration. Ensure that you read all the material within each subsection, that is, read 2.4a, 2.4b, 2.4c, 2.4d)

 

Recommended: The rest of that site -- i.e. the sections on 3,4,5,6,7, or further European, Asian, and African population movements -- is useful background to the history of North America.

   
Canada’s First Nations  www.ucalgary.ca/applied_history/tutor/firstnations/ Required: all sections.

Tip: click on "sitemap" to see an overview of the contents of the site.

   

 

3 Homework for today, Oct 17 was: complete this 2% seminar participation exercise. Write a 350-500 word reflection based on the online reading for Oct 17.

Answer any one of these questions, or write on another theme emerging from the readings. How much of this history of Canada and North America did you already know / which parts of this are new to you? Does this information contradict anything you believed, or impressions that you had? What do you think about the processes by which reservations were established, and land treaties were signed? How does this information connect to the patterns outlined by Hughes, or the stories told by King? 

Be ready to talk about your answer in class.

If you need to cite or quote material from one of those online sources, use this format:

Bibliography entry:

AHRGUC 199-2001: section 1.1.  The Applied History Research Group at the University of Calgary  (AHRGUC). Website: Peopling North America: Population Movements and Migration. Section 1: Early Migration to the Americas. Subsection: 1.1: Problems in the Study of Early Migration. SITE URL:  www.ucalgary.ca/applied_history/tutor/migrations/ Date checked: 14 October 2005.

In-text citation: (AHRGUC 1999-2001: section 1.1)

 

 

4 Reading for next week, October 24

* Complete the online reading for October 17 if you didn't already

* Read selections from Geoffrey York's book, The Dispossessed: Life and Death in Native Canada

Required selections to read: Foreword, Introduction, Chapter 2 (From Lytton to Sabaskong Bay: Fighting for the Schools), Chapter 3 (Inside the Reserves), Chapter 8 (From Manitoba to Massachussetts: The Lost Generation), and Chapter 9 (The New Militancy).

The rest of the book is well worth reading, too, but not required for this course.

Two copies of the book (not photocopies) are reserve at the Scott library, and there are also several photocopies available for borrowing outside KD's office, Vari 2029.

In addition, there are multiple copies of the book on the shelves in the Scott Library, available for borrowing. There are different editions (different years), but all will be fine for this reading. These are the call numbers: E 78 C2 Y67 1999, E 78 C2 Y67 1992, E 78 C2 Y67 1989

 

 

5   In class on Oct 24, I'll distribute the syllabus for the rest of the course, with details of further readings and assignments.

Initial classes:  introduction to the general issues of being indigenous today, and to the problematic relationships between the colonizers and the colonized.

This week (Oct 17): the specifics of the population history of Canada and North America -- who lived here when -- and next week (Oct 24): the contemporary and recent realities of life for Native peoples living within Canada.

Rest of the course: a series of themes specifically concerning Indigenous peoples and archaeology.

 

7  ASSIGNMENT 2 Preliminary information.

 

To help you brainstorm for topics: you could look at these sites for ideas:

Archaeology News: http://www.archaeology.org/online/news/headlines.html

More archaeology news: http://www.atrium-media.com/rogueclassicism/categories/explorator/

World Archaeological Congress meetings/papers: http://www.wac.uct.ac.za/wac4/wac3311.asp

http://ehlt.flinders.edu.au/wac/site/confer_nz2005.php

 

 

 


 

Discussion

 

In the video:

Consider both the information imparted about Canadian history, and the images given of Native Canadian peoples. How does this popularized national history compare to the versions you read for today? Are there stereotypes or conventions in the representation of First Nations?

 

 

For class today, you were asked to write a reflection and be ready to talk about it, on this topic:

Answer any one of these questions, or write on another theme emerging from the readings.

How much of this history of Canada and North America did you already know / which parts of this are new to you?

Does this information contradict anything you believed, or impressions that you had?

What do you think about the processes by which reservations were established, and land treaties were signed?

How does this information connect to the patterns outlined by Hughes, or the stories told by King? 

 


 

Some key points from the readings

Overall: these readings are intended to give you some sense of the depth and diversity of First Nations cultures, and the processes of colonization as they unfolded in Canadian history.

But there are other lessons, too, about how to learn about the past.

From the First Nations Tutorial page on Possible Approaches to and Perspectives of Native History http://www.ucalgary.ca/applied_history/tutor/firstnations/approaches.html

- different approaches to how we might really know the Native past

- to this we would add both Native oral history and scholarship, and archaeology

Similarly, in the section on Contact
http://www.ucalgary.ca/applied_history/tutor/firstnations/encounters.html , there is a discussion of the uses of oral history and archaeology as well as historical documents

 

Why is this question of methodology so important?

 

 


 

 

Links related to video:

Beothuk people and Shanawdithit

http://www.heritage.nf.ca/aboriginal/beo_language.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanawdithit

http://www.mun.ca/rels/native/beothuk/beo2gifs/texts/shana2.html

http://radio.cbc.ca/programs/thismorning/lfnsound/musical_memories/musical_memories_091300.html