Exam
or Test?
I tend to use the word test
instead of exam because I hope it implies less of a level
of intensity and terror. What is more important is the distinction
between exam and FINAL EXAM. Most of my courses
have a final exam substitute rather than a formal final exam (given during York's formal final exam
period in the 2-3 weeks following the end of classes). In the
courses I teach, tests (or examinations or experiential explorations into
the wealth of knowledge you have gleaned or whatever you wish to call them)
are given during the twelve weeks of the course and meet the
Senate standards for tests given during that time.
Rationale
for Tests
The purpose of tests is twofold: to motivate you
to learn the material, and to provide a method of individual
assessment required by the North American education system of
which York University is a part. You are expected to know the course
material, to understand terms and concepts and to be able to
apply them, usually to previously unseen material.
General
Form of Tests
Most courses I teach will have one
in-class test; only in the double-time summer version of Consumer Behaviour is
there no test. Tests cover all course material up until the time of the
test; this means anything and everything covered in any way in a
course. You may be asked in an open or closed book
test to analyze a case,
to apply theory to course readings or to outside materials, or
to new material, to answer short-answer or short
or long essay questions, to answer multiple choice questions
(but not in Gender Issues or Marketing for Competitive Advantage),
or to do anything that may in any way be seen as something that
will help show your mastery of the material. The point is to learn the material, not the
test, and to be aware that all course materials including final
exam substitute projects are fair game for test questions. While I
give you some idea of what a test will be like, what I have
written on the course syllabus and on this page is all I am going
to tell you about a test, so do not ask me for more information. Learn
the material and be ready
for a test that may come in any form.
Although your own
experience is a valid and important source of learning, on a
test do not limit your thinking to only your own experience. For
example, in answering a marketing question about the meaning of
a T-shirt, although to you it might be just something you wear
to the gym, think more broadly about how many different things a
T-shirt might be to a marketer. |
|
Tests in courses I teach tend to favour students who are
active in the course and who do their fair share of
group work. If you miss
a class discussion, video, guest speaker, or a particular
Discussion Group, find out what happened and catch up. Students have told me that
one of the ways my tests tend to be harder or different is that
I am often asking you to think and to apply, rather than to
regurgitate. You are told on the individual course syllabus
how many tests there are, when and where they are given, and
what each test covers. If you're required to read a book and the
test blurb does not specify specific chapters, you can safely assume
that you should read the whole book. If there are additional
required readings, they too
are fair game. Even with readings which are only recommended, you can assume that while there may not be
specific questions on the material in those readings, papers
earning top marks will incorporate some of the those
readings into their answers.
Check the blue list of links at the top of this page for
reference to the tests in specific courses I teach.
Preparing
for Tests
I have adapted this list over the years from an article in The Teaching
Professor. If you get back a test on which you did
poorly and wish to discuss your mark, first prepare a copy of
this list and circle the numbers of those statements
to which you can honestly answer "Yes." Also bring with you your classroom or Internet
notes, your study materials, review sheets you've prepared,
answers you've written for Waving Hand Exercises, submissions
you have made for any Assignments and the comments you
received back on those, in short - all the
materials that you used to study for the test, so we can try to
get an idea where you can improve next time.
Preparing for
Tests
-
I prepare
by doing the readings as assigned and on time.
-
I allow at least 1 hour for reading each assigned piece, so
I can read it slowly and thoughtfully
-
I read to ask
"why?" in addition to "what?" because I really want to know how to be an effective student, and I ask myself after reading what I have read (your professor always failed this one
miserably! I'll still sometimes read a whole page and have no idea
what I've just read).
-
I read more than the minimum required, including outside material to keep my knowledge and understanding
current.
-
I read all
notes and materials provided, asking questions
where I don't understand something.
-
I watch
videos used in the course to understand how they relate to
course material, not just to be entertained.
-
I read the
Course Kit to be sure I know about the professor’s teaching and
test philosophy.
-
I attend
and participate in classes or the Discussion
Group regularly
whether or not there are marks for it because it is one of the best ways to learn.
-
I stay for the full
class, or log into all
Discussion Groups, and attend group
meetings, so I feel like a participant and not merely a passive observer.
-
I take notes or otherwise keep track of discussions of course materials.
-
I ask questions if I am not sure about
something; this
helps me feel part of the course instead of an observer watching others learn.
-
To help combat
test anxiety, I have
contacted the Counseling Centre about workshops they
offer (416-736-5225).
-
I organize a study group of 3 or 4
fellow students with whom I review the course materials prior to the
test. To see a study group in action, rent the
film Paper Chase.
-
If I miss a class or
Discussion Group, I borrow notes
and otherwise
catch up.
-
I get a good night's sleep (7 or 8 hours) prior to the day of the
test, eat a
high protein meal before
it, and have made some effort to find what stress
relief methods work for me. Don't take this
last recommendation lightly: the brain is
the largest energy-hog in the body, and studying uses up more
energy than many physical activities. Eat well and get plenty of
rest, just like an athlete in training.
|
The time to start studying for
tests is the first day of class. There are things you can do in
order to perform better on tests. Read what I wrote recently,
challenging a student who, shocked by his low mark, wrote me
claiming, "I did
my very best." Read about Reappraisals
if you are still unhappy with your results.
A major rule of test preparation is to try to relax. Whatever works for
you, be it meditation, a chat with a friend on the phone, or a good
(but light) meal before the test (my personal favourite
in MBA days), do it in a calm and deliberate way. EVERYONE is nervous on tests. I don't believe
that in a half century of being either a student or a
teacher, I have ever met anyone who was not nervous on a test.
It is perfectly
natural: it doesn't mean you are incompetent or ignorant, just
that you are nervous. So find a way to relax, including
such things as remembering to BREATHE, that you can do before the test, as you start, and several
times during one.
While studying, think ahead about what kinds of
things you may be asked on a test. Remember that a test is your opportunity to show the
professor how much you have learned (learned, not memorized). One of the
skills a university education teaches you is how to decide what
is important. Take for example, a question in the Gender
Issues course about the
interrelationship between sexual stereotyping and sexual
harassment. Ways these two terms are related
include the fact that they both start with the letter
"S" and they are both topics in the course, but that won't earn you any points in a
university level course. They also are related in that they both cause health-related stress
problems, but while that is related to issues of gender in management,
it's not a major focal point of the course as it would be if you
were studying health policy. You have limited space in which to
write your answer so move on and try to find
the most important ways these terms are related, given
the course you are taking. One important point that you would
know from attending class is that
they feed off each other, that sexual harassment is often
based on stereotyping and stereotyping fosters the kind of
thinking that leads to the poisonous kind of work environment in
which sexual harassment flourishes.
For in-class tests, in the week before, we usually have a
REVIEW period and for Internet courses we do this
online. There is a forum dedicated to Questions about the Test.
Log in and ask questions. You may receive answers from me, or
from other students. Come prepared; during this time, I will answer almost
any question about the test, including "Will you
ask about X?". You can ask me anytime, publicly or
privately, to explain Hunt's Three Dichotomies model or to tell
you what I think Frances Hesselbein meant by the Web of
Inclusion. But if you ask me
privately "What's going to be on the test?" my answer, in the
interest of keeping a level playing field, will always be, "Ask me during the review
session," or "Ask me in the Discussion
Group," because I don't like giving special hints to
only some students. I only give them in public sessions where
everyone has a chance to hear or read it. Open
Book Tests
At a "open book" test in any classes I teach,
you may have with you anything except another person (that
includes one on the other end of a cell phone or other medium of
exchange). Remember that given that I am more concerned with
how you can think and express yourself and apply material to new
situations than I am with what you can memorize, I am
particularly not interested in reading how much you can
copy from a textbook or from my own web notes (acts which
are both plagiarism if you do not cite the source). Use your own words
on tests; don't use quotations. I'm
more interested in what you have to say than whom you can quote.
Use your time wisely to prepare beforehand for an open book
test. Use sticky-notes and bookmarks and highlighters to help
you quickly find major concepts you might need. Prepare the same review sheets you would make for a closed-book test; the process
of doing that is one of the best ways to prepare for any
test. Read about Taking
Tests on this page. If you suffer from test anxiety, contact the many services at York that help you deal with
it through workshops and counselling (e.g.:
Counseling Centre).
Learning
Disabilities/ Special Needs
While I am supportive of
Special Needs students, there are limits
to what I can do for you. I can, for example, give you more time
in which to take a test, but I cannot excuse you from one, particularly in a
knowledge-intake course which leads to other courses in
the programme such as Introductory Marketing. Read the Ground Rules Policy Page on Special
Needs. If your main problem is with multiple choice
tests, recognize that most students have problems with them and
this most likely is not considered a learning disability. Much of the problem arises from the mistaken belief that
all multiple choice questions are just memory exercises; mine
are not. See elsewhere on this page examples of multiple
choice questions I use.
Finding
Your Test Room
Use the
York
Campus Map to locate the room where your test is being
held.
What
To Bring to a Test
You must bring a valid York University student I.D.,
and a soft #2 lead pencil (in case we use scan sheets). You
don't
need a calculator and may not have one with you; I usually ask some sort of math-based question on
Marketing tests if only to remind you that Marketing is
strongly based in Economics and Finance and deeply related to
Accounting, but the challenge is in the
conceptualizing, not in the calculation and any calculations
will be simple enough to do by hand. If English is a problem, you may bring a
cloth or paperback dictionary (not electronic). This will be inspected.
Test
Room Security
For closed-book tests, you will be asked to put ALL
additional materials and belongings at the front or
sides of the test room, so do not bring anything to the
test room that
you do not specifically require with you during the test.
Internet
Course Tests
All tests for Internet courses are held
on-campus; if you live more than three hours away from York,
contact the Office of Computing Technology and e-Learning
Services and they will make arrangements for you to take
the test near where you live under supervised conditions. There
is a fee for this because it is a specialized service not
required by all students.
Taking
Tests
RULE NUMBER ONE: READ INSTRUCTIONS. The worst mistake
students make in tests is failing to read or follow instructions.
Just as my lawyer/former student James Tomlinson tells us about
being a lawyer, that the most important thing you do is learning
the other guy's case as well as your own, so should you put
yourself in the shoes of the professor who will be grading your
test. Remember that we don't as a rule like grading by
arbitrarily saying "This is an A level paper and this is a
B+" so we tend to ask questions knowing to some
extent what we will look for, keeping room on that list for
great things that students will write that we
may have missed ourselves. You are graded in comparison with
other students. Know that I never deduct more marks for wrong answers
than for blank ones so never
leave an answer blank. It is better to offer what you worry might be
a silly answer; no one will laugh at you (except perhaps
my dog when I read it to her while I am marking) and it
may possibly
earn you the point or two that could make the difference in your
final mark. I have even been known to give a grace mark
(e.g.: to raise a 79% to an 80%A) for a good sense of
humour.
Exam
(Test) Anxiety
Everyone suffers from it occasionally,
and some of us more than others. I ALWAYS suffered from
it. Here, from an article in the April 2004 York
Magazine are some suggestions on how to best avoid exam
stress:
Avoiding Test
AnxietyAttend
the last class before a test (in Internet courses join in the
asking and sharing of answers to review questions online)
Be as prepared as you can be. Don't
underestimate how much preparation you will need to do to score well.
Have a game plan. Focus on the job:
you're there to answer the questions, not to focus on how poorly
you think you're doing, how fast a classmate is writing, or what
the result of the examination means for your future.
Plan to use the entire time
allotted. Think your way through each question Remember:
answering all the questions and getting 75% correct is better
than answering half the questions had having them 100 percent
correct.
Bring your own "relaxers" into the
exam (test) room. Having "quiet" food, juice, good-luck charms,
extra writing tools, etc. can help you feel more comfortable.
|
Ten Secrets Brochure
Click here for some good
Suggestions on
Taking Tests, from the
Counselling Centre.
Multiple
Choice Questions
Don't think you can "ace" a multiple choice
test by simply memorizing the textbook and online
materials and don't think
that you have to memorize to pass one. If you have
studied the textbook and backed up that knowledge by
working through the Waving Hand Exercises (which give
you some added depth and give you a chance to use some
of the terms in real life - e.g.: see the Peter Drucker
WHE in the Strategy Unit) you should be learning the
material. Questions are chosen to make
you think about the concepts involved, and ask you to
compare, contrast, analyze, or use theories and concepts
and terms. They are chosen randomly from the test bank
that accompanies this textbook, the idea being that if
this test is made for tens of thousands of people taking
Introductory Marketing with it, you should be able to do
reasonably well on it, having read and studied the
textbook. There are some very specific questions, things
you may not remember from your studying. No one is
expected to make 100% on a test; these questions
separate the A from the B from the C paper.
There are techniques to
taking multiple choice tests. If you don't do well on
them, talk to people you know who do, use all resources provided
such as study guides, practice questions,
and classroom or Discussion Group reviews, and talk to the
Counseling Centre
about workshops. Whether or not you are a Distance
student, read here on the Office of Computing Technology
and e-Learning Services 's information sheet their Hints
for Multiple Choice Tests.
Sometimes I take my own tests to see how I do. On a
recent one, I missed six of my own questions. Here's what I did
wrong; you may find my mistakes helpful. Remember as you read through
these mistakes that I am taking a test that I myself made up,
and to which I supposedly knew the answers.
Louise's
Errors on Her Own Multiple Choice Test |
I didn't read all the
answers. I saw (a), thought to myself, yes it's (a) and
marked it, neglecting to read the other answers and
realize that yes it's (a) but it's also (b) and (c) and
(d) and therefore the correct answer should have been
(e) all of the above (dumb!) |
I was thinking about
something else. The most important step in process X is
- and I put (b) but that's the most important step in
Process Y and I didn't stop to think whether I was
thinking about the right process (lack of
concentration) |
I didn't test my answer by
reading it back to myself. On one that I missed, if I had
just read it back to myself with the answer I'd chosen,
I'd have seen that it was not logical, but I did it
quickly and didn't go back and test my answer (lazy) |
I forgot to think in terms
of the textbook and the course. I answered something
that might possibly be considered correct, but didn't
think to be sure I was using specific marketing terms
from this textbook (careless) |
I got fooled by one of
oldest test devices there is - the made-up word. They
put in an answer that doesn't exist, but it looks close
enough to something you know so you see it and think,
yeah, that's it! instead of stopping to think whether it
really is a valid term (stupid!) |
I got tired. I realized
marking it that I'd just answered (b) because I was
tired of thinking, and the answer was (d). I'd read them
all; I was just too tired to think through them all
again. This is why it's so important to come to a test
refreshed and fed. If you possibly can, and I know it's
hard, get to campus an hour earlier, get some protein
into your system, and sit and relax for a bit. You need
your energy and you can't keep up the stamina needed for
an test on a coffee and donut. |
Read carefully, concentrate, read ALL the
answers before answering, think, test your logic, be sure you
have read the question properly, take your time, remember to
breathe every so often, and stop occasionally to shake out your
hand for writer's cramp. The following is a list of hints for
performing on multiple choice tests from my own
personal experience a while ago.
Ripley’s Hints for
Passing Multiple Choice
Tests
(and all tests for
that matter)
(from personal experience taking the test for my A-Z
truck driver's learner's permit)
- Study as much as you can
- If you are told to study something,
study it
- Try to second-guess what will be
asked; think like an examiner; remember
clues provided
- Learn answers to all sample
questions; sometimes they show up on the test
- READ and FOLLOW INSTRUCTIONS
- Read questions and answers
carefully
- Double-check everything,
testing your chosen answer against those you did not
choose
- Don't panic if you cannot answer
something; stay calm and work through it
- Look for
answers that are obviously wrong to help narrow the
range of choices
- Use what you already know from
other courses and life; you know a lot more than you
think
- Visualize - learn things in charts
and pictures (this is why we use visual
aids in teaching)
- Look for consistencies - how are
questions asked; what does the examiner assume?
- Establish consistencies - if figures are
given in metric and Imperial, learn only one
- Don't get philosophical; with four
choices plus “e) All of the above" e is not
one of the four
- Guess as a last resort; I correctly
guessed on polarized glad-handles
- Don't leave any answers blank
- Don't fight the system; learn the
rules and play the game
|
Examples
of Questions from
Introductory Marketing Tests
These are from Introductory Marketing but may be
useful to any student.
There are no copies of my past tests in the
libraries or copy shops. Online Study Guides contain
examples of multiple choice questions from the test banks that I
use to construct some of the tests in some of the courses I
teach.
Introductory Marketing tests are always closed-book and consist of
either multiple-choice or short-answer, or a combination of both. Tests
also may include longer written
answers but will not include any essays. Learn the material, and
expect the test to come in any of a variety of combinations of
parts. The chapters covered during the course are covered in equal weight. See your
course syllabus for what is covered on the test.
Multiple Choice
Questions in Introductory Marketing Tests
Multiple choice questions are taken
from the assigned chapters in the textbook but also may cover anything we have done in
the course whether or not it is included in the assigned
reading. Short answer
questions cover anything we have done in the course and
I frequently use the
Waving Hand
Exercises and other exercises and your own
Marketing Plans as a basis for some
of these questions. The
tests are mostly objective in nature, testing your
knowledge of specific marketing facts, terminology, and
theories, and asking you to apply theory to practice,
including application to your Marketing Plan. You may be asked to
do simple calculations which do not require a
calculator.
Below are some typical multiple choice test
questions from Introductory Marketing, with an explanation
of how to think through the question. I
give detailed explanations, not to argue for a particular answer but to try to
show you the kind of thinking that goes on in the heads of the
people who write multiple choice questions and who put together
multiple choice tests. Taking these tests is a skill like anything
else, and it can be learned. Read the detailed explanations below
to get the general idea of each kind of reasoning and then apply
it to other test questions.
1. A public utility that has adopted
the marketing concept would be most likely to:
a. advertise its public service
role to improve its image with the public
b. set up a special service to improve
customer satisfaction
c. lower prices until most consumers felt
that prices were fair
d. all of the above
Don't just choose the first answer that seems to make
sense
On a recent test, so many people missed the
first question (which I had thought was an easy one to start with)
that I went back to see what was going on. The question asked,
"Today, which department is charged with understanding customers
and representing customer needs to other company departments?" If
you thought "Marketing", think again. Isn't that a pretty simple
answer? Look at the rest of the choices and you'll see in the list
below, "all departments", and, knowing about the Marketing
Concept, you will choose this one.
Don't give answers that seem too simplistic
On a recent test, I asked in the Short
Answer part, "From a Marketing Concept perspective, what defines a
high quality copy machine?" Too many students wrote things about
inexpensive ink and speed of copying, and good toner... and
probably sat there wondering, "Why is she asking us to know about
copy machines; it wasn't in the book or the website". The answer
is, of course, according to the Marketing Concept, a machine that
meets the consumer's needs.
Use what you've
learned in the course
To answer this question, you must know the
marketing concept, an important term covered in the
early part of the course. You must know
that the three cornerstones of the marketing concept are
Customer Need, Total Firm Co-operation, and Profit (or
similar objective for a not-for-profit
organization). Think it through. It obviously
cannot be "c" because consumers might just want to pay
nothing at all but one of the cornerstones of the marketing concept is
to earn a profit. If it can't be "c" it also cannot be
"d. all of the above." It cannot be "a" because
you will have learned in the first unit that it's not enough to just
tell people how great you are; you have to show them by action.
Therefore the answer is "b". In doing this, the company
works together to focus on what the consumer needs,
while still making a profit and staying in
business. |
2.
Which one of the following organizations is least likely to need marketing
skills?
a.
a clothing manufacturer
b. a university
c. an electronics retailer
d. a doctor
e. all of the above need marketing skills
Don’t
be stubborn!
Students sometimes want to argue that the question
asks for "one" organization, and indeed it does. But note
that it also gives you as a fifth possibility to choose all of them.
Don't blow two points trying to make a statement that "e" is
not one of the four because of course it is not. You choose among
a,b,c,d - or you can choose e. They are all valid choices. I don't ask trick
questions; take them at face value. Likewise, if you think you've found a grammatical
error, don't blow two points giving an answer that you think proves a
point about grammar, especially if Fowler's English Usage
eventually proves you wrong (true story from a class one summer).
|
3.
Shareholders would be considered part of which of the following
publics?
a.
internal
b. local
c. financial
d. media
e. all of the above
Eliminate what it can’t be
Maybe it's been a rough day and you're not
remembering that shareholders are considered part of the
organization's "financial" public. But take what you know
and use it to eliminate some of the choices. You know that
shareholders are not the media (their job is not to report in the
newspapers on what's happening) and therefore you know the answer is
not "d". You also now know that it's not "e" and
if you had to guess, you're now down to three choices instead of five.
Among the remaining choices, think about the
difference between "internal" and "local."
Certainly a shareholder may be an internal member of the organization
(profit sharing). But look at "local." Do you think that all
shareholders live right in the neighbourhood? No. Now you're down to
two choices.
Go back to "internal." You're still
wondering if you can call shareholders "internal"
because they are part of the firm (your text is clear on this,
but remember that we're talking test anxiety and forgotten readings that you'll remember
the minute you walk out of the room). Look instead at the next
choice: financial. HINT -
Read ALL possible answers, even if you think you've seen the right one
the first time. Use what you know from other courses; think about one of the basic precepts of business
that you learned Introduction to Administrative Studies or in your experience in business. What's the main
goal of any firm? Profit, or its equivalent in not-for-profit firms.
I'm not saying that's right, but it's generally the case. Who provides the
money? The shareholders. There's your answer. C - the
shareholders are your financial public.
|
4.
As a firm moves into the marketing concept, it is likely
to:
a.
place less emphasis on profit
b. adopt a more narrow view of marketing
c. worry less about customer satisfaction and concentrate on
competitors
d. coordinate firm’s marketing
activities throughout the organization
Remember
visual aids
Professors
don't just make fancy coloured overheads and draw elaborate diagrams
on the board and on websites to entertain themselves (oh, well, maybe
occasionally...it can be fun). Those visual aids are there because as educators we
know that more than 80% of people do most of their learning visually. So, when you're sitting
in the test room, wracking your brain for some crucial
fact, think back to the lecture or Internet unit or reading or
group discussion you participated in (this is where it helps to have
participated). Can you conjure up any visual images?
|
In
lectures or notes on the Marketing Concept while I'm talking
to you about the three cornerstones of the MC, I have this
picture on the overhead. I point out that the triangle,
the linking lines, the whole visual concept supports the idea
that a good marketer must have all three of these things, and
that they are equally important. A three-legged stool cannot
stand without one of its legs. A four-legged one might, but a
three-legged one can't. |
When
I talk about objectives in Unit 2, I use the same image, because the concepts
are basically the same and I link them with the same visual
image. Combine this with the hint above and begin to eliminate what you
know it can't be. If they are equal cornerstones, you can't have less
emphasis on profit, or on customer satisfaction. If everything is going to relate to
marketing (the total firm effort), then the view of marketing can't be
more narrow, so the answer must be d: coordinate the firm's activities
(total company effort).
|
|
5.
The present state of our knowledge about consumer behaviour is such
that:
a.
all relevant dimensions can be easily identified and measured
b.
we still must rely heavily on intuition and judgment to explain and
predict consumer behaviour
c.
a marketer can always rely on the text’s integrating framework to explain and predict consumer behaviour
d.
all of the above are true
e.
none of the above are true
Use what you already
know
I
ask this question on an in-class review before we've covered the chapter on Consumer Behaviour. The point is to show you
how much you already know on which you can draw when taking tests. What
is the current state of our knowledge about consumer behaviour? Do
you think it could possibly be "a"? Even if you don't yet
know the formal terms for dimensions of consumer behaviour-- can we easily find and measure all
of anything about
people's buying? Would you be willing to agree that everything you buy
is rational, sane, programmed, orderly, with reasons for purchase easily identified and
catalogued? What about that gizmo you bought to put on your desk? What
about the $300 dress you wore only once? What about the gadget you bought for your car at Canadian Tire just because it looked
neat but you've never used it? Do you really think a marketer can easily identify and measure
all the things that make you buy?
Watch
out for these words in multiple choice tests:
all |
none |
never |
always |
completely |
They
usually signify that an answer can't be right just by common sense. Do
you think it's possible that in a future chapter we will learn that marketing
managers can completely rely on the text's frameworks to predict what
people will buy? If so, do you think I'd be here writing long-winded
explanations to my students of how to think during tests? Wouldn't I
be out selling whatever it is that I know you will buy and making millions?! So
we know it's not "a" and we know it's not "c" and
therefore not "d". What about "b"? Does it look
like a reasonable statement? It should, especially if you're a
business student (or liberal arts major taking a dip in the pool).
Choice "e" might throw you a little; it's meant to. No one
is supposed to make 100% on tests. Hint:
STAY CALM AND DON'T PANIC; try using what you already know
|
6.
Mission statements should be:
a.
specific, realistic, motivating
b. specific, realistic, simplistic
c. realistic, motivating, simple
d. motivating, simplistic, specific
e. simple, specific, realistic
The
kind of question I try very hard not to ask you
These can be too frustrating
and I hated them as a student. There are several places where it is
important that you know the first step in something; for example, in
Marketing Research you must know that the first step is to define the
problem, and I might ask you a question about that, but I won't ask you things
like this where you would have to have memorized the list and the list
once shuffled around like this becomes impossible to remember.
|
I don't often discount a
question, but where I can clearly see that
a large number of students may have been confused by things beyond their control, I may do so. Discounting
a question means you get credit for it no matter what
answer you gave. This is one of the interesting things
about teaching the North American view of Marketing to a wide range of
different students in a large multicultural city. Not everyone has heard of a baby grand piano,
or of other cultural items, and the
people who make up the questions in the test banks I use (and I too
sometimes) make the assumption that you will know what one is. There are limits to how much slack I
will cut you. Recently someone wrote me that
they did not know what a Rolls Royce is, and I guess I
figure anyone studying Marketing ought to know something
that well-known in the world!
|
Short-Answer Questions
In Introductory Marketing
When using short-answer questions, I use
the
Waving Hand
Exercises in the online units
and exercises from the text and study guides and CD-ROMs
when we use them. I've even taken some word-for-word.
Sometimes I'm asking you
things that test your knowledge of specific
terminology and theory that is important for you to know in
Marketing. One of our top Marketing writers is
Shelby Hunt, and I use his Three Dichotomies
Model of Marketing as a basis for much of what I
teach about Marketing. I usually
will ask you something about the people whose
work forms the basis of what we are studying.
Limited Space in
Which to Write Answers
You will note that in all cases for Short
Answer questions, you are given a limited amount
of space in which to write your answer. This is
so that everyone has an equal chance at earning
points. Obviously if I gave you a full
page to write on each, even in a situation where
you didn't know much about the topic, you'd
probably stumble upon enough stuff to earn a few points.
But you can't do that here. You must know the
material well enough to be able to write the
correct answer in the limited space given. I do
not give marks for anything written outside the
given lines or on the back of the page, and if
you do it too often, I deduct marks. Write only
in the space allotted.
1. Using
Hunt's
Three Dichotomies model of Marketing, in which one of his
eight cells would you place each of the following scenarios?
(Answers
are Below)
1. I am a marketing manager for Procter and Gamble and I want to know
what price I should charge for a new bar of soap we are
bringing out
Micro or Macro?
/
Normative or Positive?
/
Profit or Not-for-Profit?
|
2.
I am the chair of the Gentlemen's Auxiliary for the
Toronto Symphony, and I want to know what price I should
charge for tickets to our fund raising dinner/dance next spring.
___________________/_____________________/____________________ |
3. The Toronto Children's Aid Society is purchasing
advertising on the local radio station. They want to know
what kind of advertising has been effective for other
children's aid societies in Canada.
___________________/_____________________/____________________ |
4. I am the VP of Marketing for General Mills and
I'm interested in the idea of a fat-free mayonnaise but I
have some concerns. I want to know
whether a member of the general public can really fully
understand nutrition claims made by manufacturing firms.
___________________/_____________________/____________________ |
Return to Unit 1
Leavitt |
Sometimes I want to be sure
you know some important basic terms and concepts
(3) 2. List the three main parts
of the marketing concept.
____________________________
____________________________
____________________________
|
We do this in a multiple
choice question also; sometimes there are repeat
questions on tests and you should watch for them
and use your answers to each to double check
each. The (3) tells you that the answer is worth 3
points. The three short lines tell you that you are to write three
short things. In our large classes, I do not
read anything written outside the lines. You will be
reminded of this on each test, but it is worthwhile
thinking about now. If you are used to just filling in a
whole page with stuff hoping you will happen upon the
right answer, it will not work on my tests. |
|
You don't always have
to remember every part of a theory or precisely the term
used in the textbook.
(3) 3.
List three of the five criteria for determining whether
a market segment is worth going after, and give an
example of their application in your Marketing
Plan.
1._____________________________
Plan:________________________________________________________________________
2._____________________________
Plan:________________________________________________________________________
3._____________________________
Plan: ________________________________________________________________________
Note
that these are not obscure little elements scrounged up from
unread chapters of the textbook; we read about them in the text,
worked with them in course units, and they form the basis of your
segmentation in your Marketing Plan. Still, there were five
criteria and I've only asked you for three; no one can
remember everything. Note too that it is more important
that you know the concept than that you remember the exact
phrase. If you call one of the criteria: "the thing must
work," that is good enough. The correct name is "actionability,"
but if you’ve got the idea you get credit.
I ask questions on
tests about the theory and terminology you have
been using in your assignments. In the question
above, you have to have been working
with your group or individually on your Marketing Plan to be able to
answer it, so do not
leave assignments until the last minute and in a course
with group work do not leave it all for others
to do. You will regret it at test time. Your examples
must be specific and show that you understand the
concept. For instance, if a criterion you mentioned
above
was "substantial," and you are marketing a new
anti-wrinkle facial cleanser, you should state
something like "ageing population means more people
worrying about wrinkles." |
|
|
(3) 4. State
whether a "Skimming the Cream" or a
"Penetration" pricing policy would be more
effective for your Marketing Plan product, and explain
why.
While I ask a lot of short answer
questions that test your knowledge of the history,
terminology, and theory of Marketing, I also ask you
questions that require you to think about what you've
learned and to apply it in a practical setting. This relates directly to your using what you
learned in university in your job: no boss at P&G is
going to ask a new Assistant Product Manager to define
"Skimming the Cream," but may well ask new
employees to justify their choice of strategy.
First of all, you have to know the
difference between these two strategies. Second, you
have to have done some work on your Marketing Plan (you
are expected to be working on this throughout the term,
not just in the last last week of classes), third, you
have to be sure you answer the question that is asked of
you, and fourth, you have to do it in a way that shows
you know what you're talking about. Below are some
examples of answers to that question and the points they
earned.
The correct answer is based in major
Pricing Strategy choices
Skimming is best
done when |
Penetration pricing
is best done when |
|
|
Demand is price insensitive
Quality and image support the higher price
There is little chance of
competitive entry |
Demand is highly price sensitive
Production/Distribution costs fall as sales rise
You expect competition
quickly |
You don't have to memorize all that,
but you do have to understand what it
means and how it works. Here is a full-point answer to
the question:
Penetration pricing will be more effective for my garden
tool kit because
demand is price sensitive, there are no price segments,
the products are not status items, and I suspect
competition will come quickly.
You don't have to memorize, and
you don't even have to list all the elements.
Usually one is enough (a key to that is how many points
a question is worth. In a 35 point essay, you better tell all you know about the thing; in a 2 or 3 point
short-answer question, just stick to the basics. When
I'm looking for a specific number of terms you will be told that
("List three of the four"). Here is another
full-point answer:
Penetration
would be more appropriate for our computer business because we would like to gain
market share and there is lots of competition from a
variety of sources.
You don't always have to remember the
exact terms; in this full-point answer:
A skimming
the cream policy would be more effective since the clothing
that is being offered in my Marketing Plan is targeting
the upper level of society who has the money to
spend.
you can see that the
writer did not use the term "price
insensitive" but obviously knew what it means to be
in that situation.
Note in all these cases, by the way,
that the students have named their Marketing Plan
product; if you're asked to relate a question to your
product, be sure you do.
I don't give many points away to
answers that clearly indicate the writer doesn't know
what they're talking about, or where the writer has not
answered the question that was asked, or where the
answer is simply wrong. On 2-3 point questions, I don't
give a lot of partial credit. Here are some zero-point
answers:
Penetration
pricing would be better as there are no manufacturers of
this product and I would be the first.
This is wrong because what
the student is describing is far more appropriate to a
Skimming the Cream policy. The student also did not
make any reference to the Marketing Plan product
referred to.
I
would use Penetration because I wanted to maximize my market
share by offering lower prices.
My comment on that answer
was: "This is a definition of penetration pricing; why is
it effective for your product?" The student has failed to
answer the question and to relate it to the product. No boss will keep you on staff
long if
you keep answering things s/he hasn't asked and failing
to answer what was asked of you.
Another zero point answer:
Because "Skimming"
is demand is price in sensitive... and
"Penetration" is demand is price sensitive,
both demand is based on one is exactly on demand,
another is demand in price.
It makes no sense.
This is not just a problem with English; I'm sensitive
to the issue of writing in a second language and I can
"translate" well, but here the student appears
to just be stringing together words from memory. The
student
also fails to address the question, which was to choose
one of the strategies.
Another zero point answer:
Penetration.
There are millions of people living in cold environments
who want to protect their gardens, and
most of them would not pay a premium price.
My comment is, "Why
would they not do so? Answer this, and you will have answered the
question." The student has some vague idea of what
penetration pricing is about, but s/he does not answer
the question, and what is written does not show an
ability to relate the theory to practice (Marketing
Plan).
Answers
to the Hunt's Dichotomy Questions:
1.
I am a marketing manager for Procter and Gamble and I want to know
what price I should charge for a new bar of soap we are
bringing out
ANSWER
micro -
internal to the organization - what price to charge, as opposed to social issues
normative -- says what
we should do, rather than describing what we actually do
profit - Procter &
Gamble is a
for-profit organization |
2.
I am the chair of the Gentlemen's Auxiliary for the
Toronto Symphony, and I want to know what price I should
charge for tickets to our fund-raising dinner/dance next spring
ANSWER
micro - internal to the organization, as
opposed to social issues, even though the organization is
a not-for-profit
normative - says what
we should do
not-for-profit - The
Toronto Symphony is a non-profit organization |
3.
The Toronto Children's Aid Society is purchasing
advertising on the local radio station. They want to know
what kind of advertising has been effective for other
children's aid societies in Canada
ANSWER
micro - internal to the firm, as opposed to
social issues; this is an organization purchasing
advertising time, even though the firm is one that deals
with social issues
positive - describes
how things are; what ads were used and were
effective
not-for-profit - CAS
is a not-for-profit organization, even though what they are
considering here is a very typical business decision |
4.
I am the VP of Marketing for General Mills. I've heard
about Kraft's proposed fat-free mayonnaise and before I
think about introducing our own, I want to know whether a
member of the general public can really fully understand
nutrition claims made by manufacturing firms
ANSWER
macro -
related to social issues - whether the public understands
positive - describes how things are: Do they
understand? not: should they?
profit - General Mills
is a for-profit organization |
|
My very favourite Introductory Marketing exam I ever gave; due to
vagaries of the calendar, I only got to do it once
(thanks to Professor John Parkinson for some of the weirder questions).
YORK
UNIVERSITY
ATKINSON COLLEGE
Department
of Administrative Studies
FINAL EXAMINATION - Part II WINTER 1996
AP/ADMS
2200.03 G INTRODUCTORY
MARKETING
PROFESSOR: Dr. M Louise Ripley
Monday, April 1, 1996
1:00 - 3:45 pm
Weighting of Final Results: Term Work:
60%, Final Exam: 40%
Time Allowed: 3 Hours
*************************************
IMPORTANT:
READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS CAREFULLY BEFORE
STARTING THIS EXAM!
1. a) Develop a full Marketing Plan for
a large teaching hospital in central Toronto. State your
assumptions explicitly. Draw positioning maps.
b) Use Transaction Cost Analysis to
determine whether you will use your own fleet of trucks to
deliver supplies to the hospital or contract this function out.
Use logistic regression to verify your choice. If you deliver
your own supplies, give a detailed rationale supporting the use
of Peterbilt trucks.
c) Extend the Marketing Plan in (a)
above to the surgery unit, with particular reference to the
performance of appendectomies. State in which of Hunt’s eight
categories this question would fall.
d) Perform an appendectomy upon yourself
(you will find a set of surgical instruments attached to this
examination paper). You may suture the incision upon completion,
but the examiners retain the right to have it reopened for
reassessment in the case of a marginal result. Two proprietary
analgesics are also attached, for your comfort. Based upon this
procedure and your answers to (a) and (b) above, evaluate your
Marketing Plan with reference to Peter Drucker’s rules for
Marketing Strategy.
Note 1.
Students may obtain bonus marks for carrying out the
surgical procedure under a disadvantage. Check below if these
apply:
i)
left-handedness
ii)
serious obesity
iii) blindness
Note 2.
Students who have already had appendectomies are
permitted to substitute one of the following procedures:
i) Colostomy
ii) Frontal lobotomy
Note a) to note 2). For obvious reasons this part of the
examination may only be attempted three times.
Note b) to note 2). Please wash your hands.
2. a) Determine and describe the best
channel system for a retail shoe store in suburban Toronto.
b) Design and build a retail shoe store,
based on (a) above. An open line of credit has been arranged at
Home Depot for you. Your first purchase should be drawing
instruments to create the architectural drawings. Please build
your store as close to campus as possible. Do not forget to
clear all construction permits with the appropriate authorities.
Former student James Tomlinson, lawyer, who spoke to the class,
is standing by to help you with legal matters.
c) Discuss the kind of service you will
offer in your store, making specific reference to Mike
Khasmanian’s talk on services marketing at his Esso station.
d) Discuss how the building of a retail
store exemplifies Arndt’s theory that marketing is mainly the
matching of supply and demand.
3. a) Create and film a 60-second
television advertisement for the MGB. The helpful staff of ITC
(Instructional Technology Centre, in the basement of the Ross
Building) has video equipment which you may use. .
b) Discuss how your advertisement
relates to Porter’s Five Forces Model of Marketing Strategy.
4. a) Start World War III.
b) Recreate the world, based on Marketing principles. Be
sure to make explicit reference to the following Marketing
theorists:
1)
Bagozzi
2) Borden
3) The Marketing Concept
4) Arndt
5) Hunt
6. Leavitt
7) Theodore L. Bagnasty
c) Comment briefly on any ethical problems you might have
with being asked to destroy the world for the purposes of a
marketing exam.
5. Stop here, put this away, and get busy on the real
exam, which follows.
APRIL FOOL! |
Examples
of Questions from
Gender Issues in Management Tests
(formerly Women and Business)
Questions on tests in
this course are likely to be very unlike anything you
will see in a traditional business course. I expect you
to, and grade you on your ability to critically read,
think, analyze, synthesize, and express yourself in
writing on any topic that touches on what we have done
in the course, using the course materials. Note that
"course materials" includes class or
Discussion Group discussions and the contribution
of guest speakers as well as the texts and work of any
kind that you are doing for your projects. You are
competing with 59 other students for the expectation of
roughly 10% A's in any given class. Those
papers that make intelligent reference to as many
elements of the course as feasible, in a well-structured
essay tend to earn the top marks.
The tests are open book.
You may bring anything except another person. Yes, you
can bring your laptop, but don't plan to spend a lot of
time surfing through the net; what is important is what
and how you write, not what you can copy from the course
syllabus. I do not test you on memorized details or specific information but rather I ask you to
write something that shows me what you have learned in
the course, given all the learning opportunities that
have been offered to you during the term. You should
plan to finish readings offered by the date of this
test, and expect that I will look for some reference to your
project.
From Winter 2014
Your Task: Read the newspaper article
attached to this page, sides one and two. (The Mommy Wars
are not about hostility, but insecurity). Then, covering
and prioritizing the course material you have worked with,
including Sanderson, the Discussion Group, and anything
relevant from your research project (Final Exam
Substitute), and remembering the dual parts of writing –
the epistemological showdown and the I statement, write on
the three underlined pages the following:
A properly structured
essay tying the content of this article to our course
material. You will be marked on essay structure as well as
on content.
From Fall 2013
YOUR TASK:
Consider Lean In
AND your online and in-class course materials (as one
example: where did you find similarities? where did you
find differences?)
Provide a title that tells what is at the heart of
what you’re going to say. Then write a not-more-than
three-page essay answering this question:
How well does the
book Lean In
coordinate with the readings and posting discussions you
have done with the online course material?
|
|
|
|
From Winter 2013 (this is
the only test that was somewhat different; they wrote an
outline instead of an essay because we had worked with
outlines that term)
Your Task: Read the short newspaper
article on the back of this sheet of paper, Making
Friends With The “F” Word, by which the author means
"Feminism". Then, covering and prioritizing the course
material you have worked with, including the discussion
board and anything relevant from your research project
(Final Exam Substitute), and remembering two dual parts of
writing – the epistemological showdown and the I
statement, write on the two underlined pages the
following:
An outline of the article, with each
major topic stated as a full sentence, and below each
major topic a list of what things from the course you
would use to back up that statement.
|
|
|
|
From
Fall 2012 (We visit Emma Goldman again)
Your Task:
Recalling all that we have covered in this course,
remembering what dian marino said about the dual role of
the epistemological showdown and the “i” statement (and
remembering that you do not construct an “i” statement
merely by putting “I believe” in front of a statement),
remembering proper structure for an outline, and taking
into account the lessons of the whole course, including
the guest speaker,
Construct the outline you would prepare if you were to
write an essay that defends the statement below. Give your
essay outline a title, and start at the very beginning
with your thesis statement. Note that you are constructing
only the outline, no introduction or conclusion needed.
Emma Goldman* would have approved of today’s trend toward
achieving a better balance between life and work for women
and men in managerial positions.
* What you need to know about Emma Goldman to answer this
question:
Emma Goldman, an American anarchist
activist and feminist was also an ardent dancer. She was
talking about her dancing at an anarchist meeting once and
a man in the group said to her that he felt dancing was
"much too frivolous an activity for an anarchist and that
she would be better off devoting her attention to more
serious affairs." Emma replied, "If I cannot dance, I want
no part in your revolution."
|
|
from
Fall 2011
Recalling ALL that you have read/seen/done in this course,
remembering what dian marino said about the dual role of
the epistemological showdown and the “i” statement, write
THE BODY ONLY of a structured and coherent essay about how
the song The Gambler relates to these major themes
in this course: Socialization, Power, Discrimination, and
Balance. Make a separate paragraph for each major theme.
Do NOT write an
Introduction or Conclusion. Do not just outline the body
of the essay as you did for the assignment. You are to
write a four paragraph essay, roughly ˝ page on each
theme, but without the Introduction and Conclusion (in
order to have time to concentrate on the body of the
essay).
While you will not be graded directly on grammar, without
proper writing I cannot tell what you mean to say so, say
it correctly. You earn marks for being creative, but your
major obligation is to address the test question being
sure to cover and prioritize the course material. You may
not use point form and you get no points for just naming
course materials.
The test is open-book to keep you from wasting valuable
time memorizing or searching memory banks; therefore I
want to see only your own words on this test. You will
lose points for any direct quotes from the text or any
other material not your own, whether in quotation marks or
not (a direct quote is three words or more).
THE GAMBLER
On a warm summer’s evening, on a
train bound for nowhere
I met up with a gambler, we were both too tired to sleep
So we took turns a-staring out the window at the darkness
Till boredom overtook us and he commenced to speak
He said, son, I’ve made a life out of
reading people’s faces
And knowing what their cards were by the way they held
their eyes
And if you don’t mind my saying, I can see you’re out of
aces
For a taste of your whiskey, I’ll give you some advice
So I handed him my bottle and he
drank down my last swallow
Then he bummed a cigarette and then he bummed a light
And the night got deathly quiet and his face lost all
expression
He said, if you’re gonna play the game, boy, you gotta
learn to play it right
(chorus)
You gotta know when to hold ‘em, know
when to fold ‘em
Know when to walk away, know when to run
And you never count your money when you’re sitting at the
table
There’ll be time enough for counting when the dealing’s
done
He said every gambler knows that the
secret to surviving
Is knowing what to throw away and knowing what to keep
‘Cause every hand’s a winner, just like every hand’s a
loser
And the best that you can hope for is to die in your sleep
When he’d finished speaking, he
turned back toward the window
Crushed out his cigarette, faded off to sleep
And somewheres in the darkness, the gambler he broke even
But in his final words I found an ace that I could keep
(Repeat chorus three times)
(ă Don Schlitz, transcribed
from a Bobby Bare recording)
For those who may never have played
poker –
A hand is the cards you
are dealt in a game
To “fold” means to
quit, to lay down your hand, and give up whatever money
you’ve put into the pot so far; likewise, to hold
means to stay in the game
In the scoring system, Aces
are best
To die in your sleep is
another phrase for to break even: to win as
much money as you lost
|
|
from Winter 2011
Introduction to the Essay:
The attached dialogue comes from our General Discussion
topic and yes, you are not responsible for those
discussions on the test, but I am excerpting on the next
page a dialogue from the discussion for the purpose of
this test.
Your
Task: Recalling
all that we have covered in this course, remembering what
dian marino said about the dual role of the
epistemological showdown and the “i” statement (and
remembering that you do not construct an “i” statement
merely by putting “I believe” in front of a statement),
remembering proper structure and content for an essay, and
taking into account the lessons of the whole course,
Write
a structured and coherent essay, not more than 3 pages, on
the topic of how the dialogue on the back of this page
relates to the issues of this course.
From the Discussion Topic, General Discussion, comes this
snippet of dialogue from the movie
Ratatouille, a
2007 animated comedy film that is about rat who becomes a
great cook. The following dialogue occurs between Collette
- the only woman chef, and another worker, Linguini, who
cleans up the garbage.
Linguini: Listen, I just want you to know how honoured I
am to be studying under such a...
Colette: [pins Linguini’s sleeve with a knife] No, you
listen! I just want you to know exactly who you are
dealing with! How many women do you see in this kitchen?
Linguini: Well, I uh...
Colette: [pins Linguini’s sleeve with another knife] Only
me. Why do you think that is? Because high cuisine is an
antiquated hierarchy built upon rules written by stupid,
old men. Rules designed to make it impossible for women to
enter this world, but still I’m here. How did this happen?
Linguini: Well because you, because you...
Colette: [pins Linguini’s sleeve with a third knife]
Because I am the toughest cook in this kitchen! I have
worked too hard for too long to get here, and I am not
going to jeopardize it for some garbage boy who got lucky!
Got it?
Linguini: Wow!
|
|
Test from Fall 2010
Introduction to the Essay:
The attached article on General Hillier appeared in a
recent Maclean’s
Magazine. (November 8, 2010) Read it with a thought to
what you are asked to do.
Your
Task: Recalling all that we have covered in this course (remembering that
“The Military” is only one small part of the whole
course), remembering what dian marino said about the dual
role of the epistemological showdown and the “i” statement
(and remembering that you do not construct an “i”
statement merely by putting “I believe” in front of a
statement), remembering proper structure and content for
an essay, and taking into account the lessons of our guest
speaker Marion Howell on leadership and management,
Write a structured and
coherent essay, not more than 3 pages, on one of these two
thesis statements (choose one; do not do both):
General Hillier offers good advice for women in
management.
OR
General Hillier’s advice about leadership is not
useful for women in management.
Test from Winter 2010
Introduction to the Essay:
One of the exercises in this course asked you to
look at an alphabetical list of qualities needed
for success in managing a career and a life, by
women but also in many cases by men as well. You
were invited to add words to this list. Think back
over this list or refer to it in your notes or
just think of five qualities that you think are
the most important qualities a woman needs. For
the sake of consistency, make these five qualities
all nouns.
|
Your Task: Recalling all that we have covered in this course, remembering what dian
marino said about the dual role of the
epistemological showdown and the “i” statement,
write a structured and coherent essay, not more
than 3 pages, that explains why you chose the five
qualities you chose as most important for a woman
to possess to succeed in managing a career and a
life.
|
Test from Fall 2009
(from the test that never happened in Fall 2005) |
|
Sally
Helgesen, writing in The Female Advantage
writes about Frances Hesselbein and the Web of
Inclusion. Hesselbein is a female CEO who uses
as an image of her work-world, not the
traditional hierarchical structure of
management, but the image of a spider web, with
her at the centre, and lines of connection
radiating out in a circle, connecting her and
every other manager. She warns us that the
traditional male view of the hierarchy is only
one view of business strategy. She says, “The
strategy of the web employs different methods in
order to achieve different goals… Emphasizing
interrelationships, working to tighten them,
building up strength, knitting loose ends into
the fabric, it is a strategy that honors the
feminine principles of inclusion, connection,
and what Carol Gilligan calls ‘being responsible
in the world.’ And by emphasizing the
continual
drawing closer and strengthening of parts, it
betrays [shows] the female’s essential
orientation toward process, her
concern with the means used to achieve her ends”
(p. 58, Helgesen 1990).
Recalling all that we have covered in this
course, remembering what dian marino said about
the dual role of the epistemological showdown
and the “i” statement, remembering that guest
speakers are also sources, write a structured
and coherent essay, not more than 3 pages, that
either defends or refutes the concept of the web
as a good structure for management. |
Fall 2008 - CUPE 3903 Strike; Test
cancelled
Test from
Winter 2007 |
|
I asked students what they wanted to write about
in the test. I gave this test after the group
told me that they would like a test in which
they had some choice, a test that asked them
about mentoring, a test that asked them about
how their view of work had changed, and a number
of them listed various specific parts of the
course that they would like to write about:
Recalling
all that we have covered in this course,
remembering what dian marino said about the dual
role of the epistemological showdown and the “i”
statement, and including reference to the course
materials, write a structured and coherent essay
of not more than 3 pages, that describes how
this course has changed your view of gender
issues in management and how that knowledge
would help you to mentor someone either at your
place of work or as a younger student at York.
While you need to make reference to important
points from Units throughout the course, focus
your essay on the one Unit that meant the most
to you and make clear in your essay which one it
is. |
Test from Fall 2006 |
|
There are
two questions; you are to choose and answer ONE
QUESTION ONLY.
(to
appreciate this question fully, you need to know
that during the course, which was taught as a
blended course - half in the classroom, half
online, I had a number of times referred the
students to this website that described the
previous tests, including making specific
reference to the question about Emma Goldman.
HINT: When professors talk about tests, do
listen!).
****************************************************************
Your Task:
Recalling all that we have covered in this
course, remembering what dian marino said about
the dual role of the epistemological showdown
and the “i” statement, including reference to
the course materials and at least one of our
guest speakers, write a structured and coherent
essay of not more than 3 pages, that defends or
attacks ONE of the following statements:
1) Emma
Goldman* would have approved of today’s trend
toward achieving a better balance between life
and work for women and men in managerial
positions.
2) Success
in managerial positions does not require the
assistance of a mentor, provided a woman has a
strong network on which to rely.
* What you
need to know about Emma Goldman to answer this
question:
Emma Goldman, an American anarchist activist and
feminist was also an ardent dancer. She was
talking about her dancing at an anarchist
meeting once and a man in the group said to her
that he felt dancing was "much too frivolous an
activity for an anarchist and that she would be
better off devoting her attention to more
serious affairs." Emma replied, "If I cannot
dance, I want no part in your revolution." |
Test from Winter 2006
(this was for my amazing group of
only 33 students who among them posted more than
10,000 Discusion Group postings) |
|
For a group that spent so very much time on the
Discussion Group, I thought what better than to give a test
question that arose out of a discussion.
Here below are some familiar voices:
Re: Gender issues in Fairytales?
Message no. 5849
[Reply of:
no. 5839] |
Author:
Lizamarie Lontoc |
Date:
Tuesday, February 7, 2006 12:57pm |
yeah i loved Dr. Seuss. i
cannot think of anything in there, but there
must be. back to the drawing board....we have to
read them again...but who has time?!!
In message 5839 on Tuesday,
February 7, 2006 12:02pm, Kristi Cater writes:
>I have every fairy tale I ever read when I was
younger running through my head! What about Dr.
Seuss - I loved those books and I can't think of
any gender issues in them but it has been a long
time since I've read them!
>>>In message 5754 on Tuesday,
February 7, 2006 8:59am, Heather Croft writes:
>>>>Yeah, what's up with that??!! All of the
Superheroes are men in
>>fairytales. Oh well, we've corrected that
gender stereotype. The superheroes in
>>this class are mostly female. ;>)
******************************************************************
When I read that exchange on February 7, I said to myself, I'm
going to find something
from Dr. Seuss
for the test so they can have a chance to read
him again! So here it is, from Horton Hatches
The Egg, by Dr. Seuss, p. 1-3:
Sighed Mayzie, a lazy bird
hatching an egg:
“I’m tired and I’m bored
And I’ve kinks in my leg
From sitting, just sitting here day after day.
It’s work! How I hate it!
I’d much rather play!
I’d take a vacation, fly off for a rest
If I could find someone to stay on my
nest!
If I could find someone, I’d fly away – free….”
Then Horton, the Elephant, passed by her tree.
“Hello!” called the lazy bird, smiling her best,
“You’ve nothing to do and I do need a rest.
Would you like to sit on the egg in my nest?”
The elephant laughed.
“Why, of all silly things!
I
haven’t feathers and I haven’t wings.
ME on your egg? Why that doesn’t make sense….
Your egg is so small, ma’am and I’m so immense!”
“Tut, tut,” answered Mayzie. “I know you’re not
small
But I’m sure you can do it. No trouble at
all.
Just sit on it softly. You’re gentle and kind.
Come, be a good fellow. I know you won’t mind.”
Eventually, Horton agrees and
tends the egg through all kinds of terrible
weather and adventures, saying repeatedly that
he will stay no matter what, because “I meant
what I said and I said what I meant; an
elephant’s faithful, one hundred percent.” The
lazy bird deserts him, and in the end the little
creature that is born looks like Horton and goes
home with him.
INSTRUCTIONS
Recalling all that we have
covered in this course, remembering what dian
marino said about the dual role of the
epistemological showdown and the “i” statement,
write a structured and coherent essay that
explores the relationship of these lines from
and summary of the story of Horton the Elephant
to issues of Gender and Management.
|
Test from
Fall 2005 |
|
Introduction
to the Essay: Sally Helgesen, writing in The
Female Advantage about Frances Hesselbein
and the Web of Inclusion, warns us that the
traditional male view of the hierarchy is only
one view of business strategy. She says, “The
strategy of the web employs different methods in
order to achieve different goals… Emphasizing
interrelationships, working to tighten them,
building up strength, knitting loose ends into
the fabric, it is a strategy that honors the
feminine principles of inclusion, connection,
and what Carol Gilligan calls ‘being responsible
in the world.’ And by emphasizing the
continual drawing closer and strengthening of parts, it betrays the female’s
essential orientation toward process,
her concern with the means used to achieve her
ends.” (p. 58, Readings Book)
Your Task:
Recalling all that we have covered in this
course, remembering what dian marino said about
the dual role of the epistemological showdown
and the “i” statement, including reference to at
least one of our guest speakers, write a
structured and coherent essay, not more than 4
pages double-spaced, that either defends or
refutes the concept of the web as a good
structure for management.
(I didn't
actually give this test; Sandi Warren hadn't
been able to make it the previous week because
of obligations of her doctoral study and could
only come on the test day and, recognizing
immediately the better value for students
between taking a test and hearing Sandi Warren
speak, I cancelled the test... well, one never
actually cancels a test, one allows anyone who
actually wants to go take it to do so in another
room; those who wanted to hear Sandi instead got
to choose taking their best essay grade as a
substitute). |
In the
Fall 2004, and Winter of 2005 I was on
sabbatical |
|
Test
from Fall 2003 |
|
Recalling
all that we have covered in this course,
remembering what dian marino said about the dual
role of the epistemological showdown and the “i”
statement, write a structured and coherent essay
that defends the following statement:
In
examining issues of gender in the management of
organization, it is clear that power and
nurturing and two opposite sides of the same
coin.
|
Test
from Winter 2003 |
|
Read
the attached article on mentors (two pages,
front and back) from a recent Globe and Mail
“Careers” section. Recalling all that we
have covered in this course including the
Discussion Group, remembering what dian marino
said about the dual role of the epistemological
showdown and the “i” statement, do the
following:
Using
this test as an opportunity to show what you
have learned from Salmansohn’s book,
Nichol’s collection of cases, and the
Discussion Group exchanges for this course, and
using the recommendations in this article, make
a detailed outline of the design for a mentoring
programme for the place where you work or a
place where you would like to work or for an
imaginary organization that you make up. Provide
support for everything you suggest with specific
reference to the course material but not by
quoting directly (i.e.: put everything in your
own words). Include specific and labeled
reference to five of what you felt were the most
important Waving Hand exchanges on the
Discussion Group, being sure that what you write
makes clear why you think these five are the
most important.
This (unlike
most GIM tests I give) is not a formal
essay. Point form may be entirely in clauses or
it may contain full sentences, but the point
about point form is that everything is clearly
and obviously present and labeled. Whether you
use a clause or a sentence, you will still need
to write clearly and concisely, making specific
reference to course material and pulling
together a coherent and sensible plan. You have
only the attached three pages in which to do
this. Do any preparatory work on scratch paper
which you will not hand in.
NOTE:
The article itself is not attached here on
the webpage; there are copyright laws against
posting an entire article on the web. The
article itself is not important; what I want you
to get is a feel for the kinds of tests I give
in this course. |
Recalling all that
we have covered in this course, remembering what
dian marino said about the dual role of the
epistemological showdown and the "i"
statement, write a structured and coherent essay
that comments on the following true story.
Emma Goldman, an American anarchist activist and
feminist was also an ardent dancer. She was
talking about her dancing at an anarchist
meeting once and a man in the group said to her
that he felt dancing was "much too
frivolous an activity for an anarchist and that
she would be better off devoting her attention
to more serious affairs." Emma replied, "If
I cannot dance, I want
no part in your revolution." |
Test from Winter
2002
Recalling
all that you have done in this course,
remembering what dian marino said about the dual
role of the epistemological showdown and the
"i" statement, write a structured and
coherent essay that answers these three
questions about this course (do not just answer
these 1,2,3 - you must write an essay that
answers these questions
What
did you learn that you didn’t know or realize
before?
What
shocked, surprised, or upset you?
What
cheered you up or encouraged you?
While
you will not be graded directly on grammar,
without proper writing I cannot tell what you
mean to say, so say it correctly. You earn marks
for being creative, but your major obligation is
to address what you are asked to do, being sure
to prioritize and cover the course material. You
may not use point form and you get no points for
just naming course materials.
Use
your sheet of references wisely; when I’m
grading the test I know everyone had one, so you
don’t earn points for fancy memorized lists or
quotes. Use that sheet mainly to keep panic at
bay when you forget something like Karsten’s
name! (in this section I had allowed them to
bring only a "cheat sheet" which can
often be an easier way to take a test than full
fledged open book)
|
In
the Fall of 2001,
I played a tape of and then gave students a
copy of the lyrics to the song
The Gambler and these instructions: |
|
Recalling
all that you have read/seen/done in this course,
remembering what dian marino said about the dual
role of the epistemological showdown and the
“i” statement, write a structured and
coherent essay about how the song The Gambler
relates to the major themes in this
course. (The main chorus lines in this song
are: "Know when to
hold 'em, know when to fold 'em, know when to walk
away, know when to run...") |
Test
from Winter 2001 |
|
Using Karsten's Chapter 7 on
"Stereotypes and Their Effects on Leadership
Perception" and one of Helgesen's stories, write an
analysis of the scene that takes place in
Alligator River from your web page readings
("Alligator River" was attached; I do
not ask you to memorize). |
For a short 10-point test in the Fall of
2000, I asked this:
Recalling all that you
have read/seen/done in this course, including
Helgeson’s Female Advantage, recalling all that
we’ve shared in the classroom, remembering what dian
marino said about the dual role of the epistemological
showdown AND the “i” statement, and remembering the
specific objectives of this course (reproduced below),
outline in one page on the back of this sheet, either
point form or essay or a combination, the
interrelationship between sexual stereotyping and sexual
harassment. (This question was one which, when I
had asked the class the week before the test for
an example of a test question so I could
demonstrate something to them, a student had
provided; I then used it as the test
question. Don't ever doubt that professors, some
of us, do listen to our students!) |
When you're given examples like this,
take them to heart; notice how often I refer to dian marino's "epistemological
showdown" and "i statements" - on the
website and in the classroom (or Discussion Group); I'm
looking for them in all the writing you do for this
course.
|
|
Example of Questions from Consumer Behaviour
Tests (note that in the Summer S1
Session of this course we don't have any tests)
Short-Answer Questions
(closed book)
(6) 1. State the basic differences between Positivist and Interpretivist approaches to consumer research. For each type, give examples of product dimensions that would be more usefully explored using that type of research over the other.
|
(6) 7. Assume you are designing a package for a new premium chocolate bar targeted to an affluent market. What aspects of perception must you take into consideration?
|
Although these are open ended questions, you are given only a specific amount of room in which to write.
There were more questions than these; this is just a
sample.
These questions are from when
I taught CB in a more traditional way. I now
teach it in the shortened summer S1 six-week term
without any tests; what you lose in test-anxiety you
more than make up for in hard work in-class and quick
turn-around assignments.
|
Example of Questions from Social
Marketing Tests
General Instructions:
We have covered a lot of material in Kotler and
Roberto’s book, Social Marketing. The text is
essentially a how-to book for social marketers. On this
open-book test, you will use all of what you have studied
so far to apply a specific marketing technique to a
specific social issue.
Social
change theory (and this course is all about social change)
maintains that there are five factors that influence how
fast and how well a new idea involving a change in
behaviour is accepted by a community. These are:
Adopters' Attitudes
Compatibility
Demonstrability
Felt Costs
Change Agent |
|
Review page 129 for
the full name and description of each factor. |
Instructions:
Consider the challenge of marketing the concept of
Canadian unity to Quebec separatists living in Montreal (a
topic no in-class group has chosen). Write five short
paragraphs on the following two pages, one for each of
these five factors,
describing briefly how each is relevant and why each is
important to the proper use of social marketing for this
particular issue.
You may write ONLY two pages (and if you have not
taken a course with me before, you need to know that this
is not an idle threat!) so take some time to
organize your thoughts. A possible organization of time
might include, “Think for 10 minutes, outline on scratch
paper for 5 minutes, re-read and add subtract or change
for 10 minutes, write final answer for 15 minutes, review
for 5 minutes.” This is just a suggestion and
constitutes neither a requirement nor a guarantee. Do not
quote from course material; the test is open-book only to
allay worries about needing a forgotten element and to
keep you from having to memorize anything.
Refer to course material only in your own words. No
points will be taken off or awarded for structure,
grammar, or spelling.
In
the subsequent year, I asked a very similar question with
a different issue -- the marketing of the idea of ceasing
to advertise to children to marketers. Some students
got wildly off base, failing to fully read instructions
and just copying the answers provided on the website from
the previous year. First of all, it was a different issue
and required a whole different set of premises, but more
importantly, you may not ever copy directly from a source
without citing - it's plagiarism, even on a test. READ
INSTRUCTIONS CAREFULLY.
Here is another test from a previous
Social Marketing class
Michael
Gilbert maintains there are four different kinds of
argument – logical, emotional, physical (or visceral),
and intuitive (kisceral). For the product for which your
group is developing a Social Marketing Plan, construct
four different and separate arguments to support or
promote your product, one for each of Gilbert’s four
kinds of argumentation. You may not combine these; there
must be four, and you must label them clearly and
correctly. At least one of the four must take the form of
an advertisement aimed directly at your target
adopter. You don’t have to be a sketch-artist to do
this; if you are creating a print or TV ad, you may just
describe it in words, but if you wish, you may sketch
something on the back unlined page.
While
you will not be graded directly on grammar, without proper
writing I cannot tell what you mean to say, so say it
correctly. This is not an essay; you do not need to worry
about formal essay structure with introduction and
conclusion; a combination of paragraph and point-form will
do. Refer to course material only in your own words. You
will lose points for any direct quotes from the text or
any other material not your own, whether in quotation
marks or not (a direct quote is three words or more).
|
Example of Questions from
Channels Tests
|
One
Test:
Read
the attached one-page case ("Selling Earth's Sounds"
from the Kotler
Introductory Marketing text).
Using
what you have learned about channels of distribution
through the Internet, outline what you would do to help
take Kevin online to achieve the distribution he wants
for his CD’s. (closed book; limited in space to one
test booklet)
|
Another
test:
In one test booklet, compare the potential marketing
strategies for X company using the Internet and using
traditional distribution channels. Give particular
emphasis to issues of relationship marketing, and
discuss briefly the problems and issues which are likely
to arise (open book).
|
Example of a Question from
a Marketing for Competitive Advantage Test
(To fully appreciate the
complexity of
this question, you must realize that the main overriding
theme of the text Zen & the Art of Motorcycle
Maintenance is that you cannot define quality)
Deferred and Make-Up Tests If you miss a test
for a good reason, you mustf register here online:
http://www.yorku.ca/laps/sas/links.html
This starts the process and will enable you to find out when and
where the make-up test will be. Further Petition information is
here:
http://www.yorku.ca/laps/council/students/petitions.html
Returning
Tests
I usually return in-class tests
within two weeks. For security reasons, I don't return the questions or any computerized
answer sheets for multiple choice questions. Tests for Internet students are mailed back by the
Office of Computing Technology and e-Learning Services
through email.
Bring any suspected inaccurate
grading (a number I added wrong, an answer
I clearly appear to have overlooked, etc.), to my
attention as soon as you look through your test paper. I will not consider anything that in my
view was not there originally; this is why if you leave
a space blank on a test, I draw a red ink line through it.
Posting
Grades
Read about this on the
Grades
Policy Page
This
page is the
final authority
on tests; we
will discuss
them in class
and Discussion
Groups but this
is the official
word |
|
|
|
|
|
|