Criteria 1: Potential Impact
a) Need – Does the product fulfill a current need in the health industry?
Level Three:
The product clearly identifies a modern need in the health industry, including the following:
- The industry/sector that needs the product.
- The people impacted by the product.
- What would happen if the product did not exist? What is the long-term impact of the issue at hand?
3 points
Level Two:
The product somewhat identifies a need in the health industry and fulfills one or two of the Level Three requirements.
2 points
Level One:
A need is not identified by this product.
1 points
b) Impact – Does the product have a positive impact on users?
Level Three:
The product is shown to positively impact the user in a visible manner and it is clear how it makes the area of need less challenging.
3 points
Level Two:
The product does not significantly impact the user (i.e., they could live life/function normally without product).
2 points
Level One:
The impact is not discussed.
1 points
Criteria 2: Creativity
a) Clarity – Is the use and design of the product clear and easy to understand?
Level Three:
The product use and design are well articulated and easy to comprehend.
3 points
Level Two:
The logic behind product design and function is somewhat communicated, though further explanation may be required.
2 points
Level One:
The product use and design is unclear and/or difficult to understand.
1 points
b) Design – Is the proposal design unique and eye-catching?
Level Three:
The proposal is eye-catching and captivates the audience with its uniqueness.
3 points
Level Two:
The proposal is interesting, but not captivating or unique.
2 points
Level One:
The proposal is lacking creativity.
1 points
Criteria 3: Innovation
a) Novelty – Is the product original?
Level Three:
The product is original or proposes an upgrade to existing technology in a novel way.
3 points
Level Two:
The product is very similar to a widely known
product and does not propose any upgrades to it.
2 points
Level One:
The product already exists and is widely known.
1 points