“Fighting words with wrongs? How Canadian anti-trafficking crusades have failed sex workers, migrants, and Indigenous communities” in Atlantis: Critical Studies in Gender, Culture & Social Justice
Indigenous populations, sex workers, and migrants have been legally, socially, and economically disenfranchised by the Canadian state in a multitude of ways—often in the name of “anti-trafficking.” In effect, state-led anti-trafficking enforcement measures fail to address the root causes of the harms created by past and present colonization, anti-sex work laws, and racist immigration measures and programs. This paper argues that anti-trafficking legislation and policies have been immeasurably harmful towards those they claim to protect.
Résumé
Les populations autochtones, les travailleuses du sexe et les migrants ont été privés de leurs droits juridiques, sociaux et économiques par l’État canadien de multiples façons—souvent au nom de la « lutte contre la traite des personnes ». En effet, les mesures d’application de la lutte contre la traite ne parviennent pas à traiter les causes profondes des préjudices créés par la colonisation passée et présente, les lois à l’encontre des travailleuses du sexe et les mesures et programmes d’immigration racistes. Cet article soutient que les lois et les politiques de lutte contre la traite des personnes ont été extrêmement préjudiciables envers ceux et celles qu’elles prétendaient protéger.
Robyn Maynard is Banier Scholar at the University of Toronto, holding a Faculty of Arts & Science Top Doctoral (FAST) fellowship.
Other publications from this author include:
- “Towards Black and Indigenous Futures on Turtle Island: A Conversation” in Until We Are Free: Reflections on Black Lives Matter in Canada, 75-94 (2020)
- Policing Black Lives: State Violence in Canada from Slavery to the Present (2017)
- “Accommodate this! A feminist and anti-racist response to the ‘Reasonable Accommodation’ hearings in Quebec” in Canadian Women’s Studies (2009)