TheCourt.ca is the premier source of commentary on, and analysis of, the work of the Supreme Court of Canada. Its goal is to be an inclusive forum for academics, practitioners and interested citizens to publish, review and discuss commentary on recent Supreme Court judgments, upcoming cases, current hearings, scholarly perspectives, practical insights, updates and more. The blog was originally founded by Simon Fodden, Professor Emeritus at Osgoode Hall Law School, and has been continuously publishing commentary since 2005. Over the years, TheCourt.ca has attracted thousands of readers and featured writing by leading scholars and practitioners.
Intentions Matter: Excluding Liability for Statutorily Implied Conditions in Earthco v Pine Valley
In Earthco Soil Mixtures Inc v Pine Valley Enterprises Inc, 2024 SCC 20 [Earthco], the Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC”) affirmed that common law principles of contractual interpretation apply to exclusion clauses under the Sale of Goods Act, RSO 1990, c S1 [SGA]. While “express agreement” sufficient to oust SGA liability must include an explicit…
APPEAL WATCH: Forfeiture Of Offence-Related Property Explored In Nguyen
The Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC”) is set to hear the appeal of Nguyen c. Director of Criminal and Penal Prosecutions, 2024 QCCA 674 [Nguyen] where the Court of Appeal of Québec (“QCCA”) overturned the decision of the Court of Québec, which held that it had jurisdiction to hear the application of the prosecution [41400].
Saskatchewan v Métis Nation: SCC on Multiple Proceedings, Duty to Consult, and Abuse of Process
The Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC”) has dismissed the appeal in Saskatchewan (Environment) v Métis Nation, 2025 SCC 4 [Métis Nation]. A unanimous court found that proceedings for judicial review which raise similar issues to ongoing or past litigation do not inherently amount to an abuse of process. In doing so, the SCC has clarified the extent to…