Winter term 2007
Political Science
AS/GS POLS 4075/5000 W 3.0 Encounters of Islam and Modernity
Course Instructor:
Professor: Sabah Alnasseri
Office Location/Hours:
Ross S634
Fridays: 12.30-14.00
E-mail:
alnaseri@yorku.ca
Telephone:
22552
Time and Location
Vari Hall 3005
Fridays: 14.30-17.30
Prerequisite / Co-requisite:
Familiarity with Middle Eastern and North African history, politics and society.
Expanded Course Description
General principles
This is a fourth year and graduate degree combined course on the issue of encounters and interfaces between “Islam” and “Modernity”. It is designed as a survey course whereby students actively participate in the debates via classroom presentations and staged controversies.
The course is designed to engage students in the contemporary understandings of Islam and modernity from within the discourses of both comparative politics and political theory.
It is neither a theological nor a philosophical seminar. Neither "Islam" nor "Modernity" stands as such here for debate.
In general, both are being constructed as homogeneous, antithetical or totalitarian subjects.
It is important to know on the one hand, how, when, why and who is speaking and to whom.
On the other hand, it is just as important to know that neither behind Islam nor behind modernity stands a uniform conception.
Quite the contrary: both represent disputed and contested conceptions.
For instance, the conceptions of Islam ranged from social order, religion, culture, state and society up to a counter world order or empire! The same applies mutatis mutandis to modernity. The selection of readings discussed in the class addresses the background of the assumed ‘encounter’ between Islam and modernity. The debates during the course also tackle the issue of ‘fundamentalism’ and its related off-shots such as clash and siege metaphors, holy war narratives, monolithic versus hybrid conventions of political community, and finally, the interaction between social and political movements in the Middle East and global politics.
We will try during the seminar to work out the ideological-political mystifications and to deliver a more realistic assessment in its place: what makes sense, makes little or no sense at all. In this context we will handle issues like secularism, subjectivity, state, political power, domination, class- and gender, violence and new world order etc.
Course aims
The course then will guide the student into these problematic, reflects upon it critically, and looks for possible alternatives to overcome the limitations of these definitions and perceptions with the aim of a different, more democratic- plural understanding of the subjects.
Students taking this course are expected to develop an informed understanding of the problematic and about ways of overcoming the simplification inherent within.
Assignment
Undergraduate
Two take home essay, 5p. each (these should include citation).
First essay: 09.02, due 23.02
Second essay: 09.03, due 23.03
Technical: 12pt font, 1,25 margin on all sides.
At the ends of the seminar there will be a two-hour in class examination for the Undergraduate.
Graduate
Two take home essays, 10p. each (should include citation).
Technical: 12pt font, 1,25 margin on all sides.
First essay: 09.02, due 23.02
Second essay: 09.03, due 23.03
Evaluation
Grading Undergraduate
20% presentation
10% class participation
20% in class examination, last day of class
50% essays
Grading Graduates
70% essays
10% class participation
20% presentation
Abbreviation
BOR: Books on reserve
CK: Course Kit
OB: Order through the bookstore
Assignment Submission and Lateness Penalties
Assignment Submission: Proper academic performance depends on students doing their work not only well, but on time. Accordingly, assignments for this course must be received on the due date specified for the assignment. Assignments are to be handed in class at the weekly assigned dates, or else during the office hours immediately before the class.
Note: the department drop box is only to be used for late papers.
Lateness Penalty: Assignments received later than the due date will be penalized as follow: one-half letter grade (1 grade point) per day of the total assignment grade will be taken out for the first 3 days. Afterwards, the assignment will only be graded at a 50% rate until 2 weeks past its due time. Past that date, the assignment will not be graded.
Exceptions to the lateness penalty for valid reasons such as illness, compassionate grounds, etc., may be entertained by the Course Instructor but will require supporting documentation (e.g., a doctor’s letter).
Important Course Information for Students
All students are expected to familiarize themselves with the following information, available on the Senate Committee on Curriculum & Academic Standards webpage (see Reports, Initiatives, Documents) - http://www.yorku.ca/secretariat/senate_cte_main_pages/ccas.htm
- York’s Academic Honesty Policy and Procedures/Academic Integrity Website
- Ethics Review Process for research involving human participants
- Course requirement accommodation for students with disabilities, including physical, medical, systemic, learning and psychiatric disabilities
- Student Conduct Standards
- Religious Observance Accommodation
- Join the Departmental E-mail List
- All Political Science majors should subscribe to the Departmental E-mail list that will post announcements about job opportunities, special events, career information and scholarships and awards. To subscribe, follow the instructions on the Department website: go to www.arts.yorku.ca/politics, click on Undergraduate Studies, and follow the instructions to: JOIN POLS - ANNOUNCE
Weekly Required Readings
Week of Jan 5
Introduction. No Readings
Important Dates
Jan 3: Winter term classes commence.
Week of Jan 12
Readings:
- Compulsory:
- Lewis, Bernard 2003: The crisis of Islam, London, ISBN: 0 297 64548 X, Ch. I and II, CK
- Huntington, Smauel P. 1996: The clash of civilizations and the remaking of world order, New York, ISBN: 0-684-81164-2, pp. 209-218, CK
- Recommended:
- Lewis, Bernard 1988: The political language of Islam, London, ISBN: 0-226-47692-8, Ch. 1 and 2, BOR
- Lewis, Bernard 1993: Islam and the West, New York, ISBN: 0-19-507619-2, Ch. 1, 8, BOR
- Rodinson, Maxime 1988: Europe and the Mystique of Islam, London, ISBN: 1-85043-106-X, BOR
Important Dates:
N/A
Week of Jan 19
Readings:
- Compulsory:
- Halliday, Fred 2003: Islam & The myth of confrontation, London, ISBN: 1-86064-868-1. Ch. 7, pp. 195-217, CK
- Lockman, Zachary 2004: Contending visions of the Middle East. The history and politics of orientalism, Cambridge, ISBN: 0-521-62937-3, Ch. 4, OB
- Recommended:
- Halliday, Fred 2003: Islam & The myth of confrontation, London, ISBN: 1-86064-868-1., Ch. 4, pp. 107-132, BOR
- Little, Douglas 2002: American Orientalism. The United States and the Middle East since 1945, Chapel Hill, ISBN: 0-8078-2737-1, pp. 9-42, CK
Important Dates:
Jan 18: Last date to announce component of final grade
Jan 18: Last day to enroll without permission of instructor
Week of Jan 26
Readings:
- Compulsory:
- Lockman, Zachary 2004: Contending visions of the Middle East. The history and politics of orientalism, Cambridge, ISBN: 0-521-62937-3, Ch. 3, pp. 70-98, OB
- Al-Azmeh, Aziz 1993: Islams and modernities, London, ISBN: 0-86091-626-X, Ch. 2 and 4, BOR
- Recommended:
- Turner, Bryan S. 1994: Orientalism, postmodernism, and globalism, London, ISBN: 0-415-10862-4, Ch. 3, BOR
- Salvatore, Armando1997: Islam and the political discourse of modernity, Berkshire, ISBN: 0-86372-196-6, Ch. 4, BOR
Important Dates:
Jan 26: Last day to enroll with permission of the instructor
Week of Feb 2
Readings:
- Compulsory:
- Lewis, Bernard 2002: What went wrong? New York, ISBN: 0-19-514420-1, Ch. 5: Secularism and civil society, CK
- Yahya Sadowski, “The New Orientalism and the Democracy Debate”, in Joel Beinin and Joe Stork (eds) Political Islam, pages 33-50, CK
- Recommended:
- Turner, Bryan S. 1994: Orientalism, Postmodernism & Globalism, London, ISBN: 0-415-10862-4, Ch. 2, BOR
Important Dates:
N/A
Week of Feb 9
Readings:
- Compulsory:
- Al-Azmeh, Aziz 1993: Islams and modernities, London, ISBN: 0-86091-626-X, Ch. 7, BOR
- Recommended:
- Sardar, Ziauddin 1999: Orientalism, Philadelphia, ISBN: 0-335-20206-3, OB
- Macfie, Alexaner Lyon (ed.) 2000: Orientalism: a reader, Edinburgh, ISBN: 0-7486-1441-9, OB
Important Dates:
N/A
Week of Feb 12 – 16:
Reading Week. (No classes.)
Week of Feb 23
Readings:
Presentation, No Readings
Important Dates:
N/A
Week of Mar 2
Readings:
- Compulsory:
- Huff, Toby E./Schluchter, Wolfgang (ed.) 1999: Max Weber & Islam, New Brunswick, ISBN: 1-56000-400-2, Ch. 1 and 9, OB
- Recommended:
- Turner, Bryan S. 1994: Orientalism, Postmodernism & Globalism, London, ISBN: 0-415-10862-4, Ch. 4 and 5, BOR
- Salvatore, Armando1997: Islam and the political discourse of modernity, Berkshire, ISBN: 0-86372-196-6, Ch. 6 and 7, BOR
Important Dates:
Mar 2: At least 15% of grade must be released to students
Week of Mar 9
Readings:
- Compulsory:
- Salvatore, Armando1997: Islam and the political discourse of modernity, Berkshire, ISBN: 0-86372-196-6, Ch. 5, BOR
- Al-Azmeh, Aziz 1993: Islams and modernities, London, ISBN: 0-86091-626-X Ch. 3, BOR
- Recommended:
- Euben, Roxana L., 1999: Enemy in the mirror. Islamic fundamentalism and the limits of modern rationalism, New Jersey, ISBN: 0-691-05844-X, Ch. 2 and 4, CK
Important Dates:
>Mar 9: Last day to drop Winter courses without receiving a final grade.
Week of Mar 16
Readings:
- Compulsory:
- Lockman, Zachary 2004: Contending visions of the Middle East. The history and politics of orientalism, Cambridge, ISBN: 0-521-62937-3, Ch. 7, OB
- Recommended
- Sardar, Ziauddin 1999: Orientalism, Philadelphia, ISBN: 0-335-20206-3, Ch. 5, OB
Important Dates:
Week of Mar 23
Readings:
Presentation, No Readings.
Important Dates:
N/A
Week of Mar 30
2-hours in class examination for Undergrad.
Take home work for Grad.
Important Dates:
Apr 3: Classes end.
Apr 11: Last day to submit winter term course work.