Susan
Herring has conducted extensive research in the area of gendered communication
patterns on computer-mediated discussion groups and espouses a difference
paradigm, which suggests women and men embrace different behaviors and
values in online discussion on listservs. Moreover, male discourse and
male values are taken as the discursive norm, which serves to marginalize
and exclude women.
Herring's
research for "Posting
in a different voice: Gender and ethics in computer-mediated communication"
culminated in 1994,
and her purpose involved the revelation
of gender differences and inequalities in regard to discursive practices
on the Net. She examined gendered behavior patterns on listservs, the
values of listserv participants, and the discursive norms of netiquette
guidelines. She triangulated her research methodology
to do so.
Herring
found that not only do men and women have different
posting styles, but they also adhere to different
values systems in regard to asynchronous communication in listservs.
in addition, male values were presented as the discursive norm in all
of the netiquette guidelines she examined,
with the exception of a few women-centred groups. Herring suggests that
the dominance of a minority of men in asynchronous communication forums
leads to an environment that many women may perceive
to be hostile.
Herrings
difference paradigm seems to relate to cultural
feminism, which suggests there are fundamental cultural differences
between men and women. The weaknesses of
her argument include the failure to sufficiently address human diversity,
similarities between men and women, differences among women, and the
fluidity of gender online. Given the rapid evolution of the Net, her
research is also dated and doesn't take any synchronous forms of online
communication into account. Nonetheless, Herring points out that online
communication is not gender neutral. Despite growing numbers of
women online, digital democracy has not been achieved. This continues
to be challenged and will hopefully be changed.